Skip to main content

City Council Budget Work Session – March 14, 2023

March 14, 2023 at 2:49 PM

  • 1 h 27 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Budget Work Session Recap: March 14, 2023

The Asheville City Council held a budget work session on March 14, 2023, to review the development of the upcoming fiscal year’s budget. The session focused on revenue outlooks, compensation costs, and the financial planning for the McCormick Field capital project. No formal votes or motions were taken during this work session.

Revenue and Compensation Discussions Staff reported that the city is in a good financial position due to better-than-expected sales tax growth, but rising costs to deliver existing services are consuming most of this growth. Specifically, staff projected a 2% growth in the property tax base, adding approximately $1.5 million in revenue with no rate increase planned, and a 5% growth in sales tax, adding approximately $3.2 million. Staff also highlighted opportunities to use one-time resources, including up to $5 million from the fund balance and $2 million from American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) dollars rolled over from the current year.

Compensation and benefits, identified by Budget Manager Taylor Floyd as the largest component of the budget, were a central topic. Staff recommended considering an across-the-board increase between 3.5% and 5% to address recruitment and retention challenges, while noting a specific request from the Asheville Police Department (APD) for a 6% increase. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated she is "leaning higher" on the salary increase range and supports the APD request but wants to understand the impact on the living wage. Council members requested specific cost breakdowns for a 5% across-the-board increase plus the 6% APD increase, including data on how many employees would remain below the full living wage. No final decision on the percentage was made.

McCormick Field Capital Project Staff presented the latest financial plan and community engagement updates for the $37.5 million renovation of McCormick Field. City Manager Deborah Campbell clarified that this portion of the work session was for information only, noting that the decision to approve the commitment for the project is scheduled for the business meeting later that same evening. Staff reported on meetings with Oakhurst and East End residents, identifying key concerns regarding parking, traffic management, noise, and communication. The team has agreed to manage parking and traffic for McCormick events and limit fireworks to specific dates and times. Staff also presented scenarios showing how state grants and facility fees could reduce the city’s annual debt service payment, confirming that using fund balance or ARPA funds for the project would allow current Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) projects to proceed without deferral, though the CIP contribution would need to increase over the next 2-3 years.

Community Input Although there was no formal public comment period, Council members relayed concerns raised by residents during recent neighborhood meetings regarding the McCormick Field project. A public commenter expressed concern about traffic and parking for non-baseball events, requesting better management and enforcement of illegal parking. Another commenter expressed a lack of trust in long-term contracts, asking what metrics ensure the contract is met if the team folds or moves. Mayor Manheimer responded that the city has asked for a guarantee of the team's financial commitment from an entity with the fiscal means to guarantee it. Additionally, a commenter suggested installing gender-inclusive or family restrooms if the cost is the same as female facilities; Chris Corral, Director of Community and Regional Entertainment Facilities, stated the design could look at that. Finally, a commenter expressed concern about using ARPA funds for McCormick Field while other high-need items, such as public safety at the transit center, remain unfunded. City Manager Campbell responded by clarifying that the ARPA funds in question were specifically designated for city use for operations and requested they not be removed so the city could free up additional revenue to pay for the project debt.

Follow-Ups and Next Steps Staff agreed to bring back specific costs and detailed analysis for the compensation strategy at the next work session on March 28. This will include the cost of a 5% across-the-board increase plus the 6% APD increase and data on employees remaining below the full living wage. Regarding the transit master plan, staff committed to bringing the finalized scope of work to a future agenda briefing, with stakeholder engagement scheduled to begin on March 20. City Manager Campbell agreed to provide information on the timeline changes and future use of the Hunt Hill facility within the next 30 days. Staff confirmed they are seeking a financial guarantor from the team to secure the 20-year commitment for McCormick Field, with Mayor Manheimer noting that the city attorney will need to "nail down and make airtight" the details. Finally, Director of Finance Tony McDowell stated that the budget team will build an increase in the CIP contribution into next year’s budget, stepped up over a 2-3 year period, to support the McCormick Field project.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches