Skip to main content

Policy, Finance & HR Committee – March 14, 2023

March 14, 2023 at 10:00 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Feb 14 meetingNext: May 9 meeting
  • 1 hlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On March 14, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Policy, Finance and HR Committee convened to review the minutes from its previous meeting, evaluate a recommendation for the city’s annual financial audit, and discuss proposed fee and charge adjustments for the 2023-2024 fiscal year.

Key Decisions

The committee took two formal votes during the session. First, the committee unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting by a 3-0 vote. Second, the committee unanimously passed a motion, 3-0, to recommend contracting with Cherry Becker, LLP for the city’s annual financial audit to the full City Council. No vote was taken on the proposed fee and charge adjustments; instead, the committee agreed to move that item forward to the full City Council for a final vote on March 28.

Discussion Highlights

The committee spent the majority of its time reviewing staff recommendations for fee adjustments across several departments. For Water Services, staff proposed increases to base fees, volumetric consumption fees, and hydrant meter rental deposits. Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed concern regarding water equity, noting that residential rates were seeing the highest increase over commercial rates in volumetric bulk discounts and asking for a broader understanding of why bulk discounts are offered. In response, Mayor Esther Manhammer explained that while residential customers are typically charged a higher rate per gallon than large users, the city had compared its rates to other municipalities to ensure they were in line with typical charges. David Melton, Director of Water Resources, added that the rate structure is not a straight across-the-board increase; larger users, such as manufacturers, pay a higher base fee to offset their higher volumetric usage.

Regarding Stormwater Services, staff proposed a 15% increase across the board to address deferred maintenance and system mapping. For Solid Waste and Sanitation, a $1 per month increase was proposed to offset rising disposal costs and support a new Solid Waste Master Plan. Greg Schuler, Public Works Director, stated that the increase is intended to keep up with the cost of providing the basic core service. In Parks and Recreation, staff proposed adjustments to cemetery fees, field usage fees, weight room fees, swimming pool fees, and after-school and summer camp programs. Councilwoman Maggie Ullman requested a clearer explanation of the thematic strategy behind these changes to help the full Council understand the balance between cost recovery, program demand, and affordability. Dee Tyrell, Parks and Recreation Director, noted that high-demand programs, particularly summer programs, often fill up within an hour of registration, prompting the assessment of whether higher charges are appropriate.

Follow-Ups

Staff agreed to provide several items of additional information for the full Council meeting on March 28. These include a document comparing Asheville’s water rate structure to other North Carolina cities with similar median household incomes and high industrial water usage; updated presentation slides for stormwater fees to match the figures in the staff report; a clearer explanation of the strategic rationale behind the Parks and Recreation fee changes; and additional information connecting the Solid Waste Master Plan to the Municipal Climate Action Plan and the city’s 50% waste reduction goal.

Impact

These discussions directly impact the utility bills and service costs for Asheville residents in the upcoming fiscal year. The proposed changes to water, stormwater, solid waste, and parks and recreation fees will determine how much residents pay for essential services and recreational programs. The committee’s decision to defer the final vote on these fees to the full City Council ensures that additional comparative data and strategic context will be available to the full body before a final determination is made.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches