Downtown Commission – March 10, 2023
March 10, 2023 at 8:31 AM
- 1 h 20 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: March 10, 2023
The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission held a meeting on March 10, 2023, to review recent priorities, discuss major development projects, and elect new officers. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, an overview of the "Project Aspire" development, updates on landscaping code revisions, and a discussion on a potential grant opportunity from the Mellon Foundation.
Key Decisions The Commission unanimously approved the minutes from the February 10, 2023 meeting. The body also voted unanimously to recommend that city staff move forward with an application for a $3 million grant from the Mellon Foundation. This grant would fund the design and engineering of PAC Square, connectivity improvements, and community storytelling and programming. Additionally, the Commission held roll call votes to elect its officers: Bryan Moffitt was elected Chair, and Andrew Fletcher was elected Vice Chair, with all present members voting in favor of both candidates.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to "Project Aspire," a mixed-use development involving the YMCA and First Baptist Church sites. Will Popquist of Planning and Urban Design described the project as approximately one million square feet, consisting of two phases with two tall buildings (15 to 18 stories) fronting Central Avenue and College Street. Popquist noted that while North Carolina law does not allow for mandatory affordable housing or rent control, the city’s primary tool is the Land Use Incentive Grant. Staff explained that the project will undergo an initial "master plan" level review, with more detailed reviews occurring in subsequent phases.
Staff also presented updates on landscaping code revisions. Vadilla Savicka of Planning and Urban Design explained that the largest change involves establishing minimum soil volumes for street trees to improve tree health. She described the likely implementation of subsurface systems, comparing them to "milk crates underneath the sidewalks," to keep soil uncompacted. The discussion also touched on a potential green roof standard to manage stormwater and improve water quality in the French Broad River.
Regarding public safety, the Commission discussed challenges related to police staffing and high housing costs. Bryan Moffitt stated he was trying to turn the conversation toward "stopgap solutions" for public safety and ambassadorship, asking what the Commission could do in the meantime. Sage Turner shared personal observations of changes on Church Street over the last two or three years, emphasizing the need to hear from residents and understand what is being done.
Community Input During the reports and updates section, a public commenter expressed concern about the lack of public safety and the difficulty of recruiting police officers due to housing costs. The commenter noted that a recent Chamber of Commerce event on this topic was so well-attended that many people were turned away, and suggested the Commission host a separate, larger, or virtual event to allow more small business owners and residents to be heard. In response, Sage Turner suggested the Commission form a subcommittee to plan a special meeting or event, potentially in a larger venue or virtually, to gather input. Bryan Moffitt agreed, noting the need to leverage current momentum and ensure small businesses (under 1,500 sq. ft.) are heard, not just large employers.
Follow-Ups Staff agreed to present Project Aspire for an informal Design Review Committee (DRC) meeting on March 23, 2023, with a formal DRC review scheduled for April 20, 2023. The Downtown Commission will review the project at its April 14, 2023 meeting. Staff also indicated they will bring final recommendations for the landscaping code changes to the Commission for input before the formal process begins with the Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council, targeting early summer (possibly June). The Commission agreed to form a subcommittee to determine the format, agenda, and logistics for a special public meeting focused on public safety. Additionally, staff and members will work on restoring the ability for buskers to sell merchandise in designated downtown spaces.
Impact These decisions and discussions highlight the Commission’s focus on balancing major development with public safety and community engagement. The approval of the Mellon Foundation grant application signals a push toward redesigning PAC Square and improving connectivity, while the landscaping code updates aim to improve urban tree health and stormwater management. The formation of a subcommittee for a public safety event addresses resident concerns about police presence and the economic barriers to recruitment, ensuring that smaller businesses and residents have a dedicated platform to voice their needs.
Meeting Video & Transcript