Skip to main content

City Council Retreat, Day 2 of 2 – March 3, 2023

March 3, 2023 at 8:50 AM

  • 7 h 17 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Retreat Recap: March 3, 2023

The Asheville City Council held the second day of its retreat on March 3, 2023, focusing on team dynamics, strategic alignment, and financial planning. The session served as a working session for reflection and information sharing, with no formal votes or motions taken. Key discussions centered on clarifying the roles between the Council and City Staff, reviewing the City’s financial position, and establishing 12-month goals for six strategic priorities.

Team Dynamics and Role Clarity The Council reviewed a self-assessment of team agreements, categorizing them as "green" (holding strong), "yellow" (wobbly), or "red" (broken down). Mayor Esther Manheimer identified the lack of clarity between the Council’s policy role and Staff’s operational role as a major barrier to effectiveness, stating, "The thing that's clearer for me is what's not clear... There's still not a lot of clarity for me... around that fuzzy, around that staff versus the role of the council." Staff member Deborah advocated for authentic communication, urging the Council to be comfortable with uncertainty. The facilitator emphasized the concept that "No Communication Equals People Make Stuff Up," stressing the need for direct dialogue. Several Council members shared personal reflections on the burden of service, with one noting that for Black women in Asheville, service often involves "fighting off harm" before it occurs. Council Member Sage Turner expressed surprise at how many colleagues felt their agreements had "wobbled and broke down," contrasting this with her own experience of agreements holding strong.

Strategic Alignment and Goal Setting Staff presented an "Organizational Work Plan" consisting of 51 key projects, aligning the City’s 2036 Vision with Council priorities. The Council agreed to rename the "Neighborhood Resilience" priority to "Neighborhood and Climate Resilience" to explicitly acknowledge climate change work. Working in small groups, the Council drafted initial SMART goals for six areas: Public Works & Cleanliness, Reimagining Public Safety, Homelessness, Reparations, Equitable & Affordable Housing, and Climate Resiliency. For Public Safety, the group focused on holistic strategies, including piloting community responder programs and investing in violence interrupter programs. For Homelessness, actions included supporting the Continuum of Care Board and finalizing the opening of two permanent supportive housing communities. The Council also committed to reviewing the findings of the "Stop the Harm" audit and formulating an action plan to respond to recommendations from the Community Reparations Commission within 12 months.

Financial and Capital Overview Finance Director Tony McDowell presented a high-level budget overview, stating that the City is in a "positive financial position" with a fund balance at approximately 22% of the budget, exceeding the 15% policy target. This is driven by strong sales tax growth, though recent trends show potential softening. Staff recommended utilizing up to $5 million of this fund balance for one-time items. Operating expenses are dominated by salaries, wages, and benefits, which account for 56% of the total operating budget. Key cost drivers for the next year include the expiration of a SAFER grant for firefighter salaries, increased health care contributions, and state-mandated retirement contributions.

Regarding the Capital Improvement Program (CIP), Staff noted that existing resources are insufficient to meet all identified needs. A significant funding gap exists in pavement maintenance; Staff estimate $7–$8 million annually is needed to maintain the current condition rating of 60 (considered "poor"), compared to the current allocation of $3.2–$3.6 million. Staff indicated that a 2024 General Obligation Bond is the primary opportunity to address these long-term capital needs. Additionally, the transit maintenance facility is past its useful life, requiring external federal or state funding for new facilities and vehicles.

Public Safety and Staffing Challenges The Police Chief discussed significant staffing challenges, noting a "10 year problem" in getting back to previous staffing levels. He highlighted that compensation is a major factor in recruitment and retention, stating, "I think we need to be the highest paid agency in the state... Our city has a reputation for being unfriendly to law enforcement." The Chief proposed running an in-house academy to allow for constant training and recruiting. Council members discussed the upcoming living wage decision, noting that Buncombe County has raised its threshold. Staff committed to providing detailed cost impact and compression data for various scenarios to help the Council make this decision.

Follow-ups and Next Steps Staff agreed to lead discussions on role clarity and committed to an iterative communication process to regularly report on the status of the 51 organizational work plan projects. Staff also agreed to review the categorization of four work plan items currently listed under "None" to ensure they are correctly linked to Council priority buckets. Finance Director Tony McDowell stated that a presentation on the Organizational Risk Assessment will be provided to the Audit Committee in March. Staff indicated that an update on the Community Responder Program will be provided to the Environment and Safety Committee in March or April. The Police Chief agreed to share exit interview data and comparative salary data with the Council. Staff also agreed to provide information on how the pavement condition rating is calculated and to look into standardized rating systems for water infrastructure. The Council identified the preparation of a 2024 housing bond as a key action item.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches