Reparations Commission – February 20, 2023
February 20, 2023 at 5:48 PM
- 2 h 16 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The Reparations Commission held a hybrid virtual and in-person meeting on February 20, 2023. The body approved the agenda and minutes as written by unanimous vote. Following a discussion regarding the potential for the policy to restrict creativity, the Commission voted to accept the Code of Ethics Policy; three hands were raised in favor, with no opposition or abstentions recorded. The Commission also voted to table the discussion of the new project timeline and recommendation template until the next meeting to allow for further review and clarification, a motion that passed with no recorded opposition. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn.
Discussion Highlights
The primary focus of the meeting was updates from the five Impact Focus Areas (IFAs) regarding their research and draft recommendations. The Education IFA presented harms including segregation, the racial opportunity gap, and high suspension rates for Black students, proposing recommendations such as Black teacher recruitment, community-based programming, and a community review board for suspensions. The Chair highlighted recent education data showing that disparities in exam results are at their highest levels since 1986, stating, "The disparities that we are addressing in education are greater now than any time that I can remember... This has stopped the harm now."
The Economic Development IFA discussed establishing small business incubators in African American neighborhoods, prioritizing Black businesses for contracts, and creating a trust for sustainability. A Commission member expressed frustration with the new project timeline, asking, "Where's the imagination in this process?" and noting, "I'm not understanding how this [Code of Ethics/Process], especially if it's coming from the city who created this in the first place... I'm just not feeling it."
The Health and Wellness IFA focused on health disparities, infant mortality, and the need for non-punitive substance abuse treatment and African American healing spaces. The Housing IFA addressed displacement due to urban renewal and gentrification, requesting data on government-owned properties previously taken from Black residents. A Commission member emphasized the need to understand the root of the problem, stating, "Data is important, but the root of the problem is the families and the homes... If you're not there with them, talking to them, seeing what impact on that is, that's where you have to start your basis from." The Criminal Justice IFA identified harms such as discriminatory policing and the school-to-prison pipeline, recommending funding for record expungement clinics and reentry services. A Commission member noted, "I have noticed that people want to perpetuate a paycheck and a program. And that hurts people who are the most vulnerable people. You have to be really on point about... what you're after."
The Racial Justice Coalition (RJC) presented on their "Walk the Walk" and "Every Black Voice" campaigns. The "Walk the Walk" survey canvassed over 300 community members, finding that of 5,797 city interviews, only 85 were Black. The "Every Black Voice" initiative has interviewed 185 community members to center Black voices in the reparations process. The RJC proposed collaborating on upcoming events, including a joint event with the Health and Wellness IFA and a housing-focused event on April 15.
Community Input
A public commenter, a resident of the Battery Park/Vanderbilt area, stated that there are hardly any people of color in their building despite a stipend from a national organization of churches, and suggested that more people of color are needed in those buildings. Commission member Bobette Mays responded, "I'm afraid that is something that we can consider as we work in dealing to the housing section," and noted that some seniors may not qualify for assistance due to income limits.
Another public commenter, a high school junior, spoke about their experience as a victim of suspension in Asheville City Schools. They requested that the commission address how racial trauma is handled for Black youth, noting that it leads to anxiety, shutdown, and contributes to the school-to-prison pipeline. Commission members expressed gratitude for the participation and eloquence. One member noted that the commenter was one of 24 individuals who had previously engaged with the group, emphasizing the personal impact of their actions. The Chair acknowledged the comment and the presence of the youth group.
Follow-ups
Staff member Christine Edwards agreed to send out the January meeting packet, which contains the recommendation template and process details, for review following the tabling of the item. The Chair asked members to consider volunteering for an audit working group, which will include city, county, and civility staff. Staff also asked members who had not completed their work/stipend agreements online to sign printed copies before leaving to ensure stipends are processed. A Commission member stated that if attendees had trouble getting tickets for the Thomas and Co. presentation at UNCA, they should contact the member directly.
Impact
This meeting advanced the Commission's work by accepting a Code of Ethics Policy and gathering detailed updates on the five Impact Focus Areas. The discussions highlighted significant disparities in education, health, housing, and criminal justice, with specific recommendations proposed for each area. The tabling of the project timeline and recommendation template indicates a need for further clarification on the process for developing final recommendations. The collaboration with the Racial Justice Coalition aims to ensure that Black voices are centered in the reparations process through ongoing community engagement and data collection.
Meeting Video & Transcript