Planning & Economic Development – February 20, 2023
February 20, 2023 at 4:00 PM
- 37 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On February 20, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Planning, Economic Development and Environment Committee held a meeting to address the reorganization of the committee and to review a proposal for a new housing study. The session served as the first meeting for the newly constituted committee, which now includes Council Members Sandra Kilgore (Chair), Sage Turner, and Maggie Ullman.
Key Decisions
The committee took two formal actions during the meeting. First, a motion was made to approve the minutes from the previous meeting, which passed unanimously with 3 ayes and 0 nays. Second, the committee voted to approve the contract for the Missing Middle Housing Study. This motion also passed unanimously with 3 ayes and 0 nays.
Discussion Highlights
Assistant City Manager Ben Woody presented an overview of the committee’s new scope, which includes reviewing policy updates for the local economy, maintaining a livable community, and providing direction on development policies and transportation standards. He outlined upcoming agenda items, including the PAC Square Visioning Project, the Duke Energy Rankin substation, the downtown bicycle lane project, the Transit Master Plan, and the "Close the Gap" transportation plan.
Staff from Planning and Urban Design, including Vidya Savitsky and long-range planner Kandra Tshoma, presented the proposal for the Missing Middle Housing Study. The study aims to identify regulatory and policy barriers to housing diversity, specifically for smaller-scale infill housing types such as duplexes, triplexes, and bungalow courts. The presentation noted that two-thirds of Asheville’s residential zoning currently only permits single-family housing. The study will include a displacement risk assessment to analyze potential negative impacts on lower-income and historically Black communities. The selected consultant team is Opticos Design Incorporated, with Cascadia Partners as a sub-consultant. The project is budgeted at $115,000 ($85,000 from Council and $30,000 from Community Economic Development) and is scheduled to run from the following month through March 2024.
Council Member Sage Turner expressed excitement about studying the topic, stating, "I just want to share how excited I am to finally be studying this... I want to intentionally connect missing middle housing to the affordability crisis... I’m shocked to hear that two thirds of the community is zoned single family." Council Member Maggie Ullman emphasized the need for varied solutions, noting, "We can’t have one size fit all solutions to our housing crisis... I think it’s also really wise that before we go in and propose any real technical changes, we bring in experts to study it in a technical way." Vidya Savitsky clarified the study's purpose, explaining, "The deliverable will be a report that will provide us with the base conditions of Asheville... and then a specific list of recommendations for changes... This isn’t going to be clear to the public. This isn’t going to change anything, but this will give us a lot more information so that we can more comprehensively be able to make changes."
Follow-ups
Council Member Sage Turner stated she would assist in developing the committee’s work plan, noting that the Housing, Community, and Development committee has successfully done this as a pilot for potential boards and commissions restructuring. Additionally, Council Member Sage Turner requested that the committee consider adding downtown economic development to their future agenda in preparation for an upcoming council retreat. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody agreed to add downtown as a future topic for the committee to refine. Deputy City Attorney Jannice Ashley noted that the city may not currently track specific metrics for the impact of previous zoning changes, such as the number of infill units constructed or lots reconfigured, and suggested this might be an area for improvement.
Impact
The approval of the Missing Middle Housing Study contract initiates a process to examine barriers to housing diversity in Asheville. By studying smaller-scale infill housing types, the city aims to gather technical data and recommendations that may inform future policy changes. The inclusion of a displacement risk assessment ensures that the study considers the potential impacts on lower-income and historically Black communities. Furthermore, the committee’s agreement to add downtown economic development to its future agenda indicates a focus on the economic vitality of the city center ahead of an upcoming council retreat.
Meeting Video & Transcript