Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee Retreat – January 26, 2023
January 26, 2023 at 9:03 AM
- 6 h 14 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee Retreat Recap
Meeting Overview On January 26, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee (HIAC) held a strategic retreat in Asheville, North Carolina. Guided by consultants from the National Alliance to End Homelessness (NAEH), the committee focused on system flow, governance restructuring, and strategic planning to address homelessness. The session was conducted in-person with a livestream available to the public.
Key Decisions The committee reached a general consensus, without formal objection, to restructure the Continuum of Care (COC) governance. This shift moves away from direct appointment of board members by City and County elected officials toward a structure controlled by the governing body itself, aiming to increase agility and independent decision-making. Additionally, the committee agreed to form six specific working groups to address immediate priorities: Governance, Encampments/Outreach, Coordinated Entry/By Name List, New Shelter Beds, Lived Experience, and Data. The group also agreed to meet at least twice a month until initial plans for these initiatives are in place.
Discussion Highlights A major portion of the meeting addressed the current "ad hoc" nature of encampment clearances. The group discussed the 24-hour notice period, the role of private property owners, and the trauma associated with displacement without adequate support, agreeing to develop a comprehensive policy involving multidisciplinary street outreach teams and coordination with law enforcement. The committee also discussed the necessity of mandating Homeless Management Information System (HMIS) participation for all funders and partners to ensure an accurate system view, clarifying that HMIS refers to HUD standards rather than specific software.
Regarding housing, the group addressed the complexities of housing vouchers and the dropping off of federal funds like ARPA. There was a consensus on the need for a private philanthropic subsidy pool to support landlords with urgent repairs and incentives. NAEH representatives emphasized the importance of balanced investment; Josh Johnson, Senior Technical Assistance Specialist for NAEH, stated, "If we invest in more shelter, but we don’t invest in more housing interventions, we’re just going to create more sheltered homelessness... If we invest solely in permanent supportive housing... we can unfortunately create more chronic homelessness." Anne Oliva, CEO of NAEH, advised that the COC board should maintain a "35,000 foot level review" to make trade-offs and recommendations to elected leaders.
Community Input Public commenters raised several concerns regarding the current system. A resident with lived experience expressed concern that current programs might not effectively reach individuals resistant to entering the system due to barriers like smoking policies or stigma. Staff responded by emphasizing the power of lived experience in ensuring the system meets the needs of those most impacted. Other commenters noted the diverse needs of people experiencing homelessness, including the preference for safe, tailored environments, such as separating those in recovery from those actively using drugs. Tim McAleer, Director of Homeless Services with ABCCM, responded, "I hear you... we need to make sure our system is client centered and client focused and not a one size fits all model... when we don’t have the diverse interventions to meet the needs of folks who have diverse needs... we label folks as being defiant to the system when their needs aren’t able to be met."
Commenters also highlighted the closure of adult and family care homes in Buncombe County, noting a drop from over 90 to 66 facilities, which reduces housing options for aging individuals with disabilities. Additionally, participants noted that city policy often counts a camp as "notified" if no one is present, leading to people returning to find belongings gone, and requested that the Department of Transportation use its land for camps and that more public bathrooms be installed downtown.
Follow-ups The Governance Working Group committed to reviewing the Spokane governing charter and other models to make recommendations to the city council and county commission within the next three months. The committee agreed to engage with individual elected leaders to ensure they are 100% behind the new governance structure and willing to continue funding the work. Staff confirmed they will ask supplemental questions about why people are not in shelter during the upcoming Point-in-Time (PIT) count to build a dataset on unsheltered homelessness barriers. A public commenter agreed to provide the exact number of beds lost due to the closure of adult and family care homes. NAEH representatives stated they would remain available for ongoing technical assistance. The committee is scheduled to meet again on February 9 to clarify work groups, invite community participation, and identify specific members for each group.
Impact This retreat marks a significant shift in how the City of Asheville approaches homelessness, moving from reactive measures to a coordinated, data-driven strategy. By restructuring governance to reduce direct political appointment and forming dedicated working groups, the committee aims to create a more agile and effective system. The focus on integrating lived experience into decision-making and addressing the specific barriers to shelter and housing access is intended to ensure that services are client-centered rather than one-size-fits-all. These changes are designed to improve the efficiency of federal funding utilization and create a more sustainable path toward ending homelessness in the region.
Meeting Video & Transcript