Human Relations Commission – January 19, 2023
January 19, 2023 at 6:11 PM
- 1 h 17 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Human Relations Commission Meeting Recap: January 19, 2023
The Human Relations Commission of Asheville convened on January 19, 2023, to address membership changes, review its annual report, and discuss a proposed ordinance regarding hair discrimination. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the November 17, 2022 session. Staff provided an update noting that the City Council had approved reducing the commission’s membership from 15 to 9 seats, with current members serving until their terms end or they resign. The Council also approved allowing up to three seats to be filled by residents of Buncombe County who do not live in Asheville.
The commission voted on the retention and removal of specific members based on attendance records. A motion to retain Commissioner Daniel Young passed by a show of hands, as did a motion to retain Commissioner Crystal Michelle Reid. Conversely, a motion to remove Commissioner Christopher Boyd for missing 75% of meetings in the prior 12 months also passed by a show of hands. Following these personnel decisions, the commission reviewed and approved its 2022 Annual Report, which detailed activities including a planning retreat, presentations on data and rules of procedure, and updates from the housing working group.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the "Asheville Crown Act," a draft recommendation to the City Council to adopt an ordinance prohibiting discrimination based on natural hair and hairstyles, based on North Carolina House Bill 170. City Attorney Brad Branham advised the commission that the existing Asheville Non-Discrimination Ordinance is broader than the proposed Crown Act, covering employment and public accommodations, and urged the commission to be specific about which parts of the Crown Act they intended to add. Commissioner Dolores Venable supported making the recommendation, stating it shows the city is "moving forward." After discussion, the commission voted to push the Asheville Crown Act recommendation to the March meeting for further refinement.
In other business, the commission voted to table a staff presentation on how the City receives complaints until the March meeting due to time constraints. Updates were provided on the Intergovernmental Relations, Community Engagement, Addressing Housing Issues, and Improving HRCA committees. During the discussion on compensation, Commissioner Daniel Young stated, "I think it's time for Asher [Asheville] to do right by us... We all got responsibilities. We got gas to get here... If they gonna use us, come on, compensate us a little bit." In response to a question from Commissioner Daniel Young regarding youth representation, staff member Kim Rooney, the City Council Liaison, noted that while the ordinance designates youth representation, there are currently no applicants. She added that Asheville does not currently have a stipend program for equity seats, unlike Durham, but suggested the Community Engagement subcommittee could bring up a recommendation for stipends.
No members of the public were present to speak during the live public comment period. The Chair stated, "No members of the public are present at this time."
Several follow-up actions were identified for the upcoming months. The commission agreed to refine the language of the Asheville Crown Act recommendation to ensure it is "bulletproof" and specific, with the goal of presenting a polished proposal at the March meeting. Chair Alma Atkins requested that all commissioners provide input to the Community Engagement Committee to help hone this proposal. Additionally, Commissioner Crystal Michelle Reid announced a housing subcommittee meeting scheduled for Saturday, January 21, 2023, at 11 a.m., and requested interested commissioners to contact her; Commissioners Daniel Young, Nnweyna Smith, and Brandon Oliver indicated interest in joining. The Community Engagement Committee also plans to compile a list of significant community events for the full commission to review in March to determine where the HRCA should have a visible presence.
Meeting Video & Transcript