Equity & Engagement Committee – January 17, 2023
January 17, 2023 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 3 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On January 17, 2023, the City of Asheville’s Equity and Engagement Committee held a meeting to review its scope and draft work plan. The committee, chaired by Councilmember Shanika Smith, focuses on ensuring equity in the provision of city resources and livelihood needs. Staff presented a draft work plan for upcoming months, which includes updates on reparations, strategic partnership funds, hybrid meetings, and community engagement initiatives.
Key Decisions
The committee voted to authorize additional staff work to develop a scope of work for an official audit. The purpose of this audit is to ensure compliance with applicable regulations and to cease harm impacting the African American community. Councilmember Shanika Smith moved to authorize this work, and the motion was seconded. A roll call vote was taken, and the motion carried with ayes from the present members, Chair Smith and Councilwoman Roney. No other formal votes or motions were recorded during the meeting.
Discussion Highlights
During the discussion of the reparations audit, Dr. Dwight Mullen, Chair of the Community Reparations Commission, stated that the audit is necessary because previous data provided to the commission was "unofficial" and fragmented. He emphasized that the audit must examine both the outcomes of policies and the internal workings of government that produce disparities, noting specifically that racial disparities do not automatically account for the specific impacts on African American women. Dawana Little, Vice Chair of the Community Reparations Commission, highlighted that the "cessation of harm" is as important as the audit itself, requesting that the full language of the "stop the harms" recommendation be included in the resolution. Staff confirmed that the resolution had been revised to include language regarding effective measures to end continuing violations in education, health, housing, economic development, and justice.
Councilmember Kim Roney expressed concern that the committee’s focus on "equity in provision" (output) might miss the root causes of disparities (input). She suggested using the ARPA COVID-19 relief funds as a case study to measure if past allocations actually addressed historic harm and asked for translation services and accessibility accommodations for deaf/hearing impaired and non-English speakers to be included in the work plan. Additionally, Rachel Taylor from the Economic Development Team provided an update on the relaunch of the Strategic Partnership Program, which now focuses on eliminating the opportunity gap for low-to-moderate income school-age youth.
Follow-ups
Several staff members agreed to specific follow-up actions during the meeting. Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager, agreed to work with Jeremy Knighton, Project Manager for Emergency Operations, to identify the appropriate time to discuss the accessibility of disaster response protocols and communication gaps, such as text-only services for deaf/hearing impaired residents. Rachel Wood also agreed to provide a redline version of the latest draft reparations resolution to the committee to clearly show changes made based on feedback. Furthermore, Rachel Wood agreed to attach a table comparing the evaluation committee’s initial recommendations for the Strategic Partnership Program with what Council ultimately adopted, to be included in materials for the February meeting. Rachel Taylor agreed to compile survey feedback from Strategic Partnership Program applicants and send it to the committee, while Christine Edwards, Project Manager for Reparations, agreed to help track document changes and clarify the scope narrowing for the committee.
Impact
This meeting established the immediate next steps for the City’s equity initiatives, specifically authorizing the development of an audit scope to address compliance and harm cessation for the African American community. The discussions highlighted the need for a more comprehensive understanding of how city policies impact different demographic groups, moving beyond simple output metrics to examine internal government processes. The inclusion of accessibility and translation services in the work plan, along with the focus on the Strategic Partnership Program for youth, indicates a continued effort to address systemic barriers in city services and economic development.
Meeting Video & Transcript