City Council CIP Work Session – December 13, 2022
December 13, 2022 at 1:49 PM
- 1 h 23 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council CIP Work Session Recap: December 13, 2022
On December 13, 2022, the Asheville City Council held a Capital Improvement Program (CIP) work session to launch the development process for the Fiscal Year 2024 budget. The meeting was strictly informational, serving as a data-sharing session to provide Council with context on the City’s capital planning, current project statuses, and long-term financial capacity. No motions were made, and no votes were taken during this work session.
Staff presented an overview of how the City budgets for capital projects, distinguishing them from operating expenses and noting a strategic shift from "pay-as-you-go" funding to debt financing through bonds. The Finance Director presented a multi-year financial model looking 20 to 25 years ahead, which indicates that current resources are fully committed to existing projects. Consequently, the model shows no capacity for new spending over the next five years without additional revenue sources or project delays. Taylor Floyd, the Budget Manager, stated, "Our current capacity to fund projects outside of the existing plan is limited... we have a lot of additional needs."
The discussion covered the status of active projects, including those from the 2016 General Obligation (GO) Bond. Staff noted that while the initial $74 million authorization has grown to approximately $91.5 million due to cost increases and added scope, all projects are scheduled for completion by summer 2023. Tony McDowell, Director of Finance, explained that while most projects come in under budget, "there's also times, particularly in the capital budget, more than the operating, where we do have to come back and add additional resources to projects" due to factors like inflation and multi-year horizons.
Specific upcoming capital needs were detailed, including the McCormick Field renovation (estimated at $37.5 million), the Municipal Building (fire station) renovation, the Duke downtown substation reconstruction, and upgrades to the transit maintenance facility and the Oakley multi-purpose facility. Council members raised several community-related concerns during their discussions with staff. One member expressed excitement about the McCormick Field renovation and asked if the private-public partnership could ensure greater public benefits, such as regional baseball use, community events, and food accessibility to address food deserts. The Capital Projects Director responded, "in the presentations, I do believe that they opened it up for more community use, but we'll certainly be responsive to that."
Another Council member raised concerns about grid security in North Carolina, arguing that new substations should be designed for long-term security and resiliency, such as battery-powered or gas-insulated systems, rather than just the cheapest option. Mayor Esther Manheimer replied, "I talked to our Duke representative for our area today, and we're going to get with each other to talk about it... So in thinking about constructing new substations, I think, I think you're right that the security issues are ramped up." Additionally, a Council member highlighted the need to align capital planning with equity and climate justice goals, asking for a review of procurement policies to support carbon reduction goals. The City Manager responded regarding legislative advocacy, stating, "Yeah, absolutely. And this is something that we do coordinate frequently with other municipalities as well as the league of municipalities to try to sync up and create a bigger, more broad coalition to make these asks."
The discussion also touched on the potential for a 2024 GO Bond referendum to address unmet capital needs. Mayor Manheimer noted, "Asheville has a funny history with general obligation bonds, which isn't a very consistent one... We have not developed that pattern." She expressed hope for a 2024 bond package to help voters understand the need for capital improvements. The City Manager emphasized debt responsibility, stating, "We're not going to ask you to extend this community in terms of what we can afford to pay for... getting into, and I guess it's not a tax base, borrowing as long as we can pay the debt service, we think is a responsible way to manage capital investments." A Council member expressed excitement about moving toward a regular bond cycle, stating, "I think us looking at that that'll allow us to get to 10-year capital ideas and and to again just meet the moment of what our community is asking us for."
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the session. The Budget Manager agreed to provide more clarity on how the numbers tie up between the memo and the five-year CIP presentation. The Capital Projects Director agreed to provide a list of the sidewalk projects comprising the $18.4 million transportation category and a detailed explanation of the spending plan for those projects. The City Manager stated, "I've had conversations with the county manager and we are gonna make that recommendation" regarding cost-sharing for the transit feasibility study. Finally, the Finance Director indicated that staff will pick up budget topics with the Policy, Finance, and HR Committee in January and February, with specific dates to be determined.
Meeting Video & Transcript