Skip to main content
  • 1 h 44 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: December 9, 2022

The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission met on December 9, 2022, to address several administrative items and a major transportation proposal. The primary focus of the meeting was the College and Patton Avenue Protected Bike Lane Project, which underwent public comment and a formal vote. The commission also approved draft action minutes from its previous meeting, discussed the transition to in-person gatherings, and outlined plans for its January session.

The commission began by approving the draft action minutes from the October 14, 2022 meeting, which passed unanimously. The central decision of the evening concerned the College and Patton Avenue Protected Bike Lane Project. Chair Bryan Moffitt moved to recommend the implementation of the project to the City Council, citing its alignment with the city’s comprehensive plan, motion plan, and downtown master plan. The motion included conditions requiring the Transportation Department to continue working with local businesses to delineate loading zones and maintain communication during implementation. The motion was seconded by Guillermo Rodriguez. The vote passed 5-2, with Bryan Moffitt, Andrew Fletcher, Kimberly Hunter, Steven Lee Johnson, Guillermo Rodriguez, and Ricardo Seijo voting in favor, while Tal Frankfurt and Ruth Summers voted against. Sage Turner was not present to vote. Chair Moffitt clarified that this is a recommendation only, as the City Council holds the final authority to approve the construction contract.

Public comment regarding the bike lane project revealed a mix of strong support and opposition. Several public commenters expressed concerns about the project’s impact on local businesses. One business owner in the Pritchard Park area noted that owners were not adequately notified until after the plan was announced in the media and cited logistical issues with loading zones for semi-trucks. Another downtown business owner and affordable housing committee chair voiced opposition due to poor community engagement and difficulties navigating the intersection of Patton and Cox Avenue for deliveries, suggesting the use of Pritchard Park as a bike corridor instead. An attorney representing the Biltmore Company requested a delay in the vote to discuss legal easement issues and safety concerns near their underground parking entrance, but Chair Moffitt did not agree to delay the vote. Other commenters raised concerns about fire truck access, the validity of traffic counts, and the narrowness of the streets. Conversely, other public commenters expressed strong support, including a resident from West Asheville who highlighted the safety benefits for families and an owner of an electric bike tour company who argued the project would improve order on chaotic streets. No specific members responded directly to these comments during the public comment period.

Following the public comment, staff and members provided additional context. Jessica Morris, Assistant Director of Transportation, addressed the safety and legal aspects, stating that the city had communicated with the Biltmore Company and that the current design includes a break in the bike lane at the driveway to manage conflicts. She also noted that the fire department has no concerns with the project, as the bike lane is wide enough to be used by emergency vehicles if necessary. Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson emphasized that the project dramatically improves public safety, noting his residence on College Street and business on Patton Avenue. Commissioner Tal Frankfurt stated he was not ready to support the recommendation, while Commissioner Ruth Summers voted against it. Sage Turner, the City Council Liaison, acknowledged the calls for more types of engagement and better tools. Chair Moffitt appreciated the dissenting votes, noting they contributed to a healthy discussion.

The commission also voted to transition from virtual to in-person meetings at City Hall, scheduled to start at 8:30 AM and end by 10:00 AM. This motion passed, with Andrew Fletcher, Tal Frankfurt, Steven Lee Johnson, Megan Rogers, Ricardo Seijo, Ruth Summers, Sage Turner, and Chair Bryan Moffitt voting in favor. Guillermo Rodriguez was absent from the call and did not vote. The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to adjourn.

Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Staff member Jessica Morris agreed to provide a similar presentation to the Planning and Economic Development Committee on January 9. She also stated that the city will continue to work with businesses along the corridor to make adjustments to loading zones if needed and confirmed that the city is purchasing equipment to help enforce loading zone time limits. Additionally, the city plans to add additional bike racks and potentially a bike corral along the corridor, though specific locations are not yet finalized. Chair Bryan Moffitt and staff member Dana agreed to create a "Doodle poll" to determine the logistics of the January meeting, which will coincide with the PACS Square Plaza Visioning Project design workshop. Chair Moffitt also stated that the commission will send out updates and reports via email for items not covered in detail due to time constraints.

This meeting is significant for residents as it moves the College and Patton Avenue Protected Bike Lane Project forward to the City Council for final decision. The project aims to improve safety and infrastructure for cyclists and pedestrians in the downtown core, a topic that generated substantial community debate regarding business logistics and emergency access. The commission’s decision to return to in-person meetings also signals a shift in how the body will conduct its business moving forward.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches