Multimodal Transportation Commission
December 7, 2022 at 3:00 PM
- 1 h 47 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Multimodal Transportation Commission Meeting Recap: December 7, 2022
The City of Asheville’s Multimodal Transportation Commission (MMTC) held a virtual meeting on December 7, 2022, to address infrastructure closures, committee memberships, and regional transit planning. The commission reviewed several agenda items, including the approval of the current agenda and a recommendation regarding the closure of an unopened right-of-way. The meeting also featured discussions on the potential merger of active transportation committees and a proposed joint planning effort with Buncombe County.
Key Decisions and Votes The commission unanimously approved the meeting agenda, with a motion made by Pat Katz and seconded by Jack Igelman. Regarding the October 26, 2022 minutes, the commission voted to table the approval until the next meeting. This decision was made after Randy Warren noted that a motion for a "smart grant proposal" was missing from the record, and staff agreed to revise the document to include it. The commission unanimously voted to recommend the closure of an unopened right-of-way associated with Central United Methodist Church, a motion moved by Pat Katz and seconded by Kenny Armstrong. This recommendation will be forwarded to City Council for final approval. Additionally, the commission unanimously voted to recommend Joseph Dessler for appointment to the MMTC, a motion moved by Pat Katz and seconded by Randy Warren. The commission also unanimously approved the reappointment of Georgia Burt for a second term on the Transit Committee, moved by Randy Warren and seconded by Kenny Armstrong. Finally, the commission unanimously endorsed the concept of a joint planning effort with Buncombe County to develop a transit master plan, a motion moved by Randy Warren and seconded by Pat Katz.
Discussion Highlights During the discussion on the right-of-way closure, Randy Warren emphasized the importance of reviewing the "bigger picture" to prevent future issues, such as large trucks blocking streets during development. Staff member Jessica Joyner clarified that permanent right-of-way closures typically do not involve physical construction but rather the legal removal of old plats from the late 1800s and early 1900s that designated streets or alleys which never materialized. On the topic of merging the Greenway Committee and the BikePED Task Force into a single "Active Transportation" committee, Randy Warren expressed support for the merger provided it was done in a "carefully structured way" that preserved public involvement and did not absorb one group into the other. Kenny Armstrong suggested rebranding the Greenway Committee as the Active Transportation Committee but expressed reservations about dissolving the BikePED Task Force, viewing it as a valuable, casual advocacy venue that could continue without official city staffing.
Community Input Two written public comments were submitted regarding the City-County Joint Transit Planning item. One commenter, identifying as a volunteer with the AARP and a member of the Archie Transit Coalition, requested the completion of early master plan phases, including evening service until 10:00 p.m. and increased frequency in South Asheville, and asked for a jointly funded feasibility study for coalition transit service. A second commenter, a West Asheville resident and Executive Director of Just Economics, spoke on behalf of the "Better Buses Together" coalition, urging the commission to prioritize a study on city-county transit collaborations, including potential system mergers and funding opportunities such as a quarter-cent sales tax. In response, Kenny Armstrong stated, "It's really refreshing to have a grassroots advocacy group come into the table... I think it's part of our job is to listen to those and move those recommendations up the chain." He expressed support for a study to explore regional transit authority options. Another public commenter noted that City Council is currently discussing enabling legislation for a quarter-cent sales tax for transit.
Follow-ups Staff member Jessica Joyner agreed to revise the October 26, 2022 minutes to include the written motion for the smart grant proposal. Regarding the right-of-way closure, the applicant, Mr. Bob Oost, stated he would correct a mistake in the written description of the property’s meets and bounds and provide the updated document to staff the following day. Staff will reach out to Joseph Dessler to confirm his interest and availability for the MMTC seat, as his application was submitted in February. Jessica Joyner stated she will speak with Dana from the Downtown Commission regarding applications for the Public Space Management Task Force, where Kenny Armstrong and Jack Igelman volunteered to fill two open transportation seats. Additionally, Jessica Joyner stated she plans to submit a budget request for the FY 2023-24 budget year for a joint planning study with Buncombe County, noting that formal conversations with county staff regarding the scope have not yet occurred. She also stated she will consult with the Greenway Committee and BikePED Task Force to ensure the proposed merger does not conflict with the city-wide review of boards and commissions, and the commission will likely revisit this topic at the next meeting.
Impact These decisions impact residents by formalizing the legal status of local infrastructure and shaping the future of regional transportation. The recommendation to close the unopened right-of-way resolves a historical land use ambiguity, potentially allowing for clearer development or maintenance of the area associated with Central United Methodist Church. The endorsement of a joint planning effort with Buncombe County signals a shift toward regional cooperation in transit, aiming to address funding gaps and service limitations that a single municipality may struggle to resolve alone. The potential merger of the Greenway Committee and BikePED Task Force could streamline active transportation advocacy, though members emphasized the need to maintain distinct voices and public engagement channels within the new structure.
Meeting Video & Transcript