Human Relations Commission
October 20, 2022 at 5:30 PM
- 1 h 18 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a regular meeting on October 20, 2022. The primary focus of the session was a discussion on restructuring the commission to improve its effectiveness, including proposals to change the board size and meeting frequency. The meeting began with a review of group norms and a roll call, which indicated that the commission did not have the required two-thirds quorum for certain actions, though it maintained a simple quorum for others.
Key Decisions The commission took several formal votes to restructure its operations. First, the minutes from the September 15, 2022 meeting were approved unanimously. The commission then voted to approve a proposal to reduce the board size from 15 members to 9; this vote was unanimous, though staff clarified that this decision serves as a recommendation that must be sent to City Council for final approval. Additionally, the commission voted unanimously to reduce the frequency of meetings from monthly to bimonthly, a change staff confirmed the commission can make unilaterally. Regarding the format of future meetings, the commission attempted to vote on continuing with virtual meetings. However, because the required supermajority of eight members was not present, the vote defaulted to in-person meetings. Staff confirmed that the commission will return to in-person meetings beginning next month. Finally, the commission agreed to move the meeting start time from 5:30 PM to 6:00 PM but decided to keep the meeting duration at 90 minutes.
Discussion Highlights During the debate on restructuring, Chair Rodriguez emphasized the need for an effective commission, stating, "It’s not that we’re cutting the commission in half... It’s that we’re letting go of the part... that is ineffective and has been consistently ineffective every meeting year after year." Commissioner Atkins suggested breaking the agenda item into two separate votes—one for board size and one for meeting frequency—to clarify the commission's stance on each issue. Vice Chair Oliver proposed using the "off months" (when no full commission meeting is held) for working group meetings, stating, "I think that would really help my schedule... I really think that would help me." Commissioner Venable expressed concern about the lack of in-person engagement, noting, "It’s very hard to have engagement when you’re not necessarily engaging with people in the most typical ways... I do think if we’re gonna do one thing, we need to kind of change to in-person." Staff member Brad Brannan also clarified the legal standing of the meeting format vote, advising against extending the timeframe for virtual meetings beyond the current vote.
Follow-ups Staff member Elena Schmidt stated she would send an email to all commission members to gather input on the new bimonthly schedule, specifically regarding days and times that work for them, before finalizing the 2023 calendar. Additionally, staff member Sarah Mastrianni stated that the boards and commissions realignment working group hopes to have a survey regarding board member experiences out by the end of the year. Vice Chair Oliver stated he would send an email to the commission with information about upcoming community events, such as a wellness event by Umoja.
Impact These decisions will alter how the Human Relations Commission operates in the coming year. By moving to a nine-member board and bimonthly meetings, the commission aims to streamline its processes, though the board size change remains pending City Council approval. The shift back to in-person meetings and the use of off-months for working groups are intended to facilitate direct community engagement and allow for continued work on specific issues between full commission sessions.
Meeting Video & Transcript