Skip to main content

Boards & Commissions

October 11, 2022 at 1:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Sep 13 meetingNext: Nov 15 meeting
  • 40 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On October 11, 2022, the City of Asheville Boards and Commissions Committee convened to review board vacancies, interview candidates for the Alcohol Beverage Control (ABC) Board Chair, and discuss the committee’s upcoming work plan. The meeting was chaired by Vice Mayor Shanika Smith.

Key Decisions and Votes

The committee took several actions regarding appointments and scheduling. First, the minutes from the September 13 meeting were approved unanimously (3-0). Regarding the vacant ABC Board Chair position, Councilwoman Kim Roney moved to recommend candidate Robin Cape, with Vice Mayor Smith seconding the motion; the recommendation passed unanimously (3-0) and will be forwarded to the full City Council for consideration. The committee also voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend Cherie Lucas for a vacancy on the African-American Heritage Commission and to appoint Eileen, Catherine, and Donald Post to the Human Relations Commission.

For other boards, the committee decided not to make immediate appointments. For the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee, the committee chose to wait for a formal recommendation from a newly formed nominating committee at the next meeting. For the Noise Advisory Board, the committee decided to re-advertise the industrial and construction representative seat because the applicants did not qualify. Similarly, the committee decided to re-advertise a position on the Public Art and Cultural Commission based on a request from the board chair. Finally, the committee agreed to reschedule the regular November 8 meeting to November 15 at 1:00 PM and to cancel the December meeting to allow for holiday application processing.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to interviewing two candidates for the ABC Board Chair: Robin Cape and Max Haener. The discussions covered their backgrounds, views on the privatization of alcohol sales, the potential impact of marijuana legalization, and approaches to hiring and evaluating the ABC Executive Director.

Vice Mayor Shanika Smith expressed her support for Robin Cape, stating, "I was very impressed by Robin Cape's proactive measures and reaching out to leaders on a state level ahead of legalization and I'm very impressed by also her knowledge of the system." Councilwoman Kim Roney added, "I feel really strongly that we're not yet ready for the big changes that are about to happen at the federal and state level and the existing communication between Buncombe County and the state is really important to me which is why I'm ready to make a motion to recommend Robin Cape for chair."

Candidate Robin Cape discussed the history of North Carolina’s restrictive control system, noting, "The state of North Carolina has one of the most restrictive control systems and as such... we also have a lot less problems with alcohol on the street than a lot of places do." She also advocated for the ABC system as a pathway for marijuana legalization, stating, "I'm just more and more become convinced and try to advocate for the fact that the ABC... could be really the healthiest way for us to move forward with legalizing marijuana in this country, state." Candidate Max Haener emphasized the leadership role of the chair, saying, "I understand that the chair is the face of the board. I understand that he or she is also a team leader." He also highlighted potential revenue benefits, noting, "As far as our county is concerned, we are mandated to contribute or to give to our city and Buncombe County 75% and 25% respectively of our profits."

Staff presented the committee work plan, highlighting upcoming topics including the "Inclusive and Accessible Government" project, board management software, and the realignment working group survey.

Follow-ups

Staff, specifically the Deputy City Clerk, agreed to provide an update on the "Inclusive and Accessible Government" project, including hybrid meeting options, at the next meeting. The Deputy City Clerk also stated that results and analysis from the realignment working group survey will be presented to the committee. Additionally, the Deputy City Clerk indicated that a budget request for new board management software is likely to be presented in the future and committed to developing a training series for board, commission members, and staff. The Deputy City Clerk confirmed that the discussion regarding reducing the membership number for the Human Relations Commission will come to this committee in November before moving to full council. Finally, the Deputy City Clerk stated they would issue notices for the rescheduled November meeting and the cancellation of the December meeting.

Impact

These decisions directly affect the composition of several city advisory bodies, including the ABC Board, Human Relations Commission, and African-American Heritage Commission. The recommendation of Robin Cape for ABC Board Chair is particularly significant given the ongoing discussions regarding alcohol regulation and the potential legalization of marijuana, as the ABC Board plays a central role in these areas. The rescheduling of the November meeting and cancellation of the December meeting will impact the timeline for processing holiday applications and other year-end administrative tasks.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches