Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
September 1, 2022 at 9:30 AM
- 2 h 10 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On September 1, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) held a remote, live-streamed meeting to review housing data, address zoning changes, and discuss internal governance. The session covered the impact of rising mortgage rates on construction, challenges faced by housing voucher holders, and preliminary discussions on source-of-income discrimination and proposed policy adjustments.
Key Decisions
The committee approved the minutes from the previous meeting via a unanimous roll call vote. Additionally, the committee voted unanimously to support a technical change to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) regarding manufactured homes. The motion stated that AHAC supports the technical change and looks forward to exploring a larger review of manufactured home policy in the future. No formal vote was taken on the logistics for a strategic retreat; instead, the Chair stated that a poll will be distributed to select dates and determine the format, with a vote expected at the next meeting. The Chair also decided that a lengthy email regarding a Habitat for Humanity project in Shiloh would be posted in the meeting minutes rather than read aloud, ensuring it is part of the public record. Finally, the Chair confirmed the plan to hold the October meeting in person, barring any changes due to health exposures.
Discussion Highlights
The committee reviewed monthly housing data, noting that rising mortgage rates are impacting construction and affordability. Paul Heathman, a Mortgage Loan Officer, noted that rates have jumped up again and that the Federal Reserve seems to be signaling this might not be the end of it, describing the situation as "hugely impactful on hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of borrowing money." Tara Irby, COO of the Asheville Housing Authority, highlighted that many voucher holders cannot find housing due to a lack of general housing stock and landlord discrimination or stigma. Nnweyna Smith, Associate Coordinator at HelpMate, added that some landlords discriminate outright to keep certain types of people off their property.
Regarding the manufactured home zoning change, Ricky Hurley, Zoning Supervisor for Development Services, explained that the change addresses an issue where a mobile home park lot becomes "dead" if a home is removed and the space remains vacant for more than six months, preventing replacement. Chair Barry Bialik emphasized the need to avoid derailing this "low hanging fruit" technical change by getting bogged down in details, while keeping the larger conversation in mind. Andy Barnett, Executive Director of Habitat for Humanity, suggested writing policies in a way that is dynamic to market changes, such as tying numbers to inflation adjustments.
The committee also held preliminary discussions on source-of-income discrimination, noting the topic is coming to the Human Rights Commission. Andy Barnett suggested the Connect Team continue to monitor and support this policy area. Councilwoman Antoinette Mosley proposed an expansion of the "20-80-20" policy to include deeper affordability, potentially incentivizing units at 50-60% Area Median Income (AMI) subsidized by higher-income units at 100-120% AMI. Chair Bialik stated this will be a future agenda item for deeper discussion, potentially supported by the Connect Task Force. On internal governance, Chair Bialik noted that stepping into leadership roles is "more than a part-time job" and asked members to consider transitioning roles, including the Vice Chair position, as the committee has one year remaining. He also expressed a preference for an off-site retreat format that is "more conducive of constructive conversations."
Community Input
A public commenter submitted a lengthy email expressing dissatisfaction with a Habitat for Humanity project in Shiloh. Staff confirmed there were no other public comments in the queue at the time of the manufactured home zoning vote. A member noted that emailing the city makes the content public record, supporting transparency by including it in meeting materials. The Chair agreed to post the email as a minutes item to satisfy public record requirements.
Follow-ups
Tara Irby stated she will ensure that unit mix and housing typology data is included in future reports to the committee. Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager, agreed to follow up with the committee regarding the status of city-owned lots intended for the Asheville Bank of Land Trust. Rachel Wood also noted that a survey will be distributed to current and former board members to gather feedback on barriers to success. Staff member Ricky Hurley will take the committee’s feedback on removing size restrictions to the next steps in the approval process, which includes the Council Committee, Planning Commission, and Council. The Chair agreed to send out a poll for retreat dates and format preferences within the next couple of weeks. Additionally, the Chair agreed to devote time in a future meeting to hear news from the North Carolina Affordable Housing Conference and to email the CED listserv managers to send out a notice about the Affordable Housing Fair.
Impact
These discussions highlight the ongoing challenges residents face in accessing affordable housing, particularly those relying on vouchers who encounter discrimination and limited housing stock. The committee’s support for the technical zoning change aims to prevent the loss of manufactured home park capacity, which is critical for housing availability. The preliminary discussions on source-of-income discrimination and the "20-80-20" policy indicate a focus on creating more flexible and inclusive housing policies that can adapt to market fluctuations and better serve lower-income residents.
Meeting Video & Transcript