Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee
August 26, 2022 at 9:00 AM
- 1 h 25 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee of the City of Asheville held a virtual meeting on August 26, 2022. The only formal vote taken during the meeting was on the consent agenda from the July 29, 2022 meeting. A motion was made and seconded to accept the agenda, and a roll call vote resulted in a unanimous passage, with all present members voting in favor. No other formal votes or decisions were recorded.
Discussion Highlights
The primary agenda item was a presentation by Christy Schulenberg and Josh Johnson from the National Alliance to End Homelessness (NATEH) focused on "level setting" for best practices in homeless response systems. The presenters clarified that "Housing First" involves immediate access to housing without readiness conditions, combined with comprehensive, client-driven wraparound services. Josh Johnson emphasized that the model "has to maintain fidelity" and is not merely about placing people in housing, stating, "It's not setting people up for failure... We're really trying to provide those wraparound services for the stability."
Committee members engaged in a detailed discussion regarding the Vulnerability Index-Service Prioritization Decision Assistance Tool (VI-SPDAT). David Nash asked if there is research identifying which specific questions in the assessment tool result in racially biased outcomes and whether documentation exists on this topic. Emily Ball, City Staff, responded that the committee is required to use an assessment through the current process and noted, "we can't just switch to a new tool because that new tool doesn't exist."
NATEH also provided an update on the comprehensive needs assessment, reporting that focus groups were complete, a community-wide survey had received 1,740 responses, and approximately 130 interviews with people experiencing homelessness had been conducted. Christy Schulenberg indicated that the final report presentation might be delayed by two to three weeks to ensure data accuracy. Vice Chair Sarah Copley stated that the adjusted timeline is "really understandable" and appreciated the efforts of the data team.
Community Input
One public comment was received via written submission from a resident identified only by initials. The commenter shared a personal experience with the VI-SPDAT assessment, stating, "regarding the vulnerability index when I was homeless and it was administered, my mental illness was so activated that I was afraid to answer the questions. So my score wasn't reflective of my needs when VIA asked what my score was to assess how they could help." Vice Chair Sarah Copley responded to the submission, thanking the individual for taking the time to educate the committee and noting, "That's very brave, and I appreciate the use of the initials."
Follow-ups
Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting:
- Needs Assessment Timeline: Christy Schulenberg stated that the presentation of the needs assessment report may be pushed back by two to three weeks to allow for additional data collection from county staff and finalization of survey data.
- Survey Extension: NATEH noted that an assistant county manager requested the community-wide survey be kept open for a couple more weeks to allow for wider dissemination throughout the county.
- Staffing: Emily Ball reminded members that job postings for three positions in the homeless services division were extended to September 6 and asked members to help disseminate the listings.
- Nominations: Jen Teague noted that one city seat and two county seats are open for appointment. The committee will elect a new Chair and Vice Chair at the September meeting, and nominations should be sent to Jen Teague.
- Code Purple: Emily Ball stated that three providers are expected to participate in Code Purple (winter sheltering) and that they are meeting next week to finalize the plan. She agreed to ensure Jessica Supik (Asheville City Schools) and Shannon Boyd receive updates on Code Purple sheltering for their family work.
- Funding Votes: Emily Ball informed the committee that a special meeting will be called for September 13 at 9:00 a.m. to vote on recommendations for Emergency Solutions Grant (ESG) and Continuum of Care (CoC) funding.
Impact
This meeting provided the committee with foundational education on the components of an effective homeless response system, specifically clarifying the role of wraparound services in Housing First models to address member concerns about safety and support. The discussion highlighted ongoing tensions regarding the use of the VI-SPDAT assessment tool, balancing the requirement to use the current tool with concerns about racial equity and disparate impacts. The delay in the needs assessment report, driven by the need for data accuracy and wider survey dissemination, indicates that the committee will continue to gather community input before finalizing its strategic recommendations. The upcoming special meeting in September to vote on funding recommendations will be a critical step in determining how resources are allocated for local homeless services.
Meeting Video & Transcript