Design Review Committee
August 18, 2022 at 12:15 PM
- 1 h 30 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On August 18, 2022, the City of Asheville Design Review Committee convened with Jeremy Goldstein serving as acting chair, as regular chair Robin Raines was out of town. The meeting included a pre-meeting discussion where staff introduced Alex Cole, an Urban Planner III who will assist with historic building reviews. Staff provided a pipeline update, noting that the project at 226 Hilliard and 85 Ashland (referred to as "The Duke") is expected to return for review, and the Acid and Sawyer Micro Housing project is scheduled for a formal review in the coming months. Staff also noted that the division is currently understaffed but is in the process of hiring new urban planners, which may allow for deeper design reviews and guideline updates in the future.
Key Decisions
The committee voted 5-0 to approve the minutes from the July 21, 2022 meeting. The ayes were Christina Roush, Steven Lee Johnson, Bryan Moffitt, Ricardo Seijo, and Jeremy Goldstein.
Regarding the exterior rehabilitation of 34 South Lexington Avenue, the committee voted 4-1 to not recommend approval of the project. The motion stated that the project does not meet the intent of the downtown design guidelines because the proposed alterations do not follow the historic pattern of the existing storefronts and transoms, and the submitted materials were internally inconsistent. The ayes were Christina Roush, Steven Lee Johnson, Bryan Moffitt, and Jeremy Goldstein; the nay was Ricardo Seijo. Staff advised the applicant that while this is a mandatory review with voluntary compliance, coming back with clearer plans would benefit the project. The applicant indicated they would prefer not to resubmit but would work with the city if suggestions were provided.
The committee also conducted an informal review of the Aston and Sawyer Micro Housing project at 46 Aston Street, which involves two new seven-story buildings and the renovation of an existing building. No formal vote was taken on this item during the meeting.
Discussion Highlights
During the review of 34 South Lexington Avenue, staff member Alex Cole stated, "While we've noted some ways that the project might better align with the guidelines... we are still recommending approval of the request." However, committee members expressed confusion regarding the submitted materials. Member Ricardo Seijo said, "I don't have enough information to vote on this or if I voted on it I would turn it down based on I can't tell what's going on... I just can't even make head or tails to figure out how we're meeting or not meeting those currently." Member Bryan Moffitt added, "I'm confused... I'm looking at the plan and the elevation and they don't remotely match up... I just can't tell what you're doing right now." Acting Chair Jeremy Goldstein stated, "I can't make a meaningful determination from what I've seen... I wouldn't be able to support it."
For the Aston and Sawyer Micro Housing project, members provided feedback on the design. Member Bryan Moffitt suggested, "I think I'd like to see you do a little bit more of that [pushing and pulling on the elevation]... The right side block looks more developed... I'd almost like to see you play... similarly, like that, that right side block is so much more successful to me than the left side." Member Ricardo Seijo commented, "I'd like to see some of that [artful playfulness] happening on the brick as well... And also, I mean, why not put some windows on it [the stair tower]?... I think it would be a shame to make that a mural." Member Christina Roush noted, "I think there's some missed opportunities like where you see the existing building... where you're just looking through this corridor between the buildings and you see just white. I'm wondering if you could break up the facade there... And I think there's a couple more opportunities to do that... where you see those peek-throughs." In response, the applicant’s representative, Brian Cook, stated, "We're trying to treat these buildings more like cousins and not siblings. So they have similar materials but not the same arrangements so that they do kind of act as their own self and own building."
Community Input
One public commenter addressed the committee regarding 34 South Lexington Avenue, stating they had no comment on the project and were only on hold in case issues arose during the informal discussion. When informed that public comment is not taken for informal discussions, the commenter ended their call. No public comments were recorded for the Aston and Sawyer Micro Housing item.
Follow-ups
Staff member Will agreed to email the entire committee the agenda as soon as it is crafted, usually a few weeks before the meeting, to provide a heads-up on major projects coming down the pipeline. Additionally, the applicant’s representative, Brian Cook, committed to taking the committee’s feedback regarding facade articulation, brick patterns, and the treatment of the stair tower back to the drawing board. He also committed to providing a landscape and site plan showing pedestrian movement and hardscape connections between the buildings by the next presentation.
Impact
This meeting resulted in the denial of the exterior rehabilitation proposal for 34 South Lexington Avenue due to inconsistencies in the submitted materials and non-compliance with historic design guidelines. The committee also provided specific design feedback on the Aston and Sawyer Micro Housing project, which will be incorporated into future revisions of the proposal. These actions reflect the committee's role in ensuring that new developments and renovations align with the city's design standards and historic character.
Meeting Video & Transcript