Skip to main content

Sustainability Advisory Committee

July 20, 2022 at 3:30 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: May 18 meetingNext: Nov 16 meeting
  • 1 h 47 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On July 20, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Sustainability Advisory Committee (SACIE) held a virtual meeting to address environmental policy updates, climate planning, and operational logistics. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of public comments, updates on the Municipal Climate Action Plan (MCAP), and detailed discussions regarding plastic reduction policies and the transition back to in-person meetings.

Key Decisions

The committee took three formal votes during the session. First, the members unanimously approved the May action minutes. Second, the committee voted 4-2 to support and recommend the adoption of a draft ordinance banning single-use plastic bags and regulating paper bags. This motion included two specific amendments: moving the provision for a 10-cent fee on recycled paper bags to the "strongly encouraged" list (making the fee optional rather than mandatory) and adding a provision allowing businesses to deplete their backstock of polystyrene (styrofoam). Third, the committee unanimously passed a motion to amend the existing leaf collection ordinance to ban the use of plastic bags for leaf collection.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the meeting focused on the Municipal Climate Action Plan (MCAP) update. Staff presented a gap analysis and a list of high-impact activities. During this discussion, a committee member emphasized the critical nature of stormwater management, stating, "If we don't have stormwater, the city is doomed. The roads are going to be torn up. The houses are going to be messed up. The river is gone. So I think if you're going to list those other things, stormwater infrastructure, the main gray infrastructure needs to be right at the top."

The debate on the plastic reduction ordinance centered on the legality and efficacy of a 10-cent fee for paper bags. Brad Branham, the City Attorney, expressed concern regarding the legal authority in North Carolina to implement such a fee, noting, "Our research at this point indicates that we would be the first to do such a thing in this or any other context... at this point, we have not reached the point of consensus on feeling comfortable that the legal authority exists in North Carolina to do this particular part of the ordinance." In contrast, Susanna Knox, a presenter from the Plastic Free WNC Coalition, argued for the fee as a best practice to encourage reusable bags, stating, "We have studied probably over 100 ordinances across the country... and believe that this is the best practice to keep people... to get people to bring their own reusable bags to the store with them." A committee member countered the necessity of the fee, saying, "I would, I'm happy to let Whole Foods decide what it wants to do... Why do we need to be reaching out at this point on this, particularly on a plastics ordinance? ... I would add two things that move the substance of Section 4 over to Section 1 [Strongly Encouraged]."

The committee also discussed the logistics of returning to in-person meetings in September, including the annual board retreat and mask policies. One committee member expressed a desire for in-person interaction, stating, "I'm a mask wearer too... I think it would be great if we could get together in person somehow. I'd really like to find out if any of you are really real people or not." Regarding hybrid meeting formats, City Attorney Brad Branham noted the technical difficulties, stating, "What is likely not to be very viable is a hybrid situation where we have some members participating virtually and some members participating remotely. That just becomes a very technological nightmare situation that we're trying to avoid."

Community Input

Public comments were received regarding the plastic reduction ordinance. One public commenter from the local Sierra Club group strongly recommended passage of the ordinance, citing the environmental costs of plastic production, microplastic pollution, and the clogging of drains and rivers, while noting that many retailers, including McDonald’s, have already eliminated plastic bags. Another public commenter from Buncombe County argued that the proposed "whereas" clauses lacked cited scientific research. This commenter suggested that areas with oil wells should produce the oil for plastic bags and asked which studies favoring paper over plastic the committee had considered. No members or staff members responded directly to these specific public comments during the meeting.

Follow-ups

Staff member Bridget Herring agreed to work with the Climate Resilience Working Group to determine prioritization factors to narrow the list of high-impact activities in the MCAP to roughly 20 items, committing to return to the committee with the top priorities after a prioritization workshop. Additionally, Bridget Herring and Chair Anna Priest agreed to determine the logistics and location for the September 21 board retreat, including whether it would be held outdoors. Bridget Herring also stated that the Sustainability Office would coordinate with the Waste Reduction Working Group to ensure the final recommendation to City Council reflects the committee’s motion on the plastic reduction ordinance, including the optional fee and styrofoam backstock provisions. Finally, Bridget Herring and City Attorney Brad Branham stated they would continue to explore legal and technological options for hybrid meetings following the expiration of the state of emergency on August 15, keeping the committee updated on what is legally permissible.

Impact

These decisions directly impact local waste management and environmental policy. The recommendation to City Council to ban single-use plastic bags and regulate paper bags, along with the ban on plastic leaf bags, aims to reduce plastic waste in the community. The ongoing work on the Municipal Climate Action Plan will shape the city's long-term strategy for climate resilience and energy efficiency. Furthermore, the committee's exploration of hybrid meeting logistics and the September retreat will determine how the committee operates in the coming months, balancing public accessibility with in-person engagement.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches