Downtown Commission
July 8, 2022 at 9:30 AM
- 1 h 8 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville Downtown Commission held a virtual meeting on July 8, 2022. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, updates on public safety and design review processes, reports from the Asheville Downtown Association, and discussions regarding homeless initiatives and downtown infrastructure projects.
Key Decisions
The commission’s only formal vote was to approve the draft action minutes from the previous meeting. A motion was made by Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson and seconded by Ruth Summers. The vote was taken via roll call, and the motion carried with all voting members voting "Aye." The meeting was subsequently adjourned by a motion made by Commissioner Robin Raines and seconded by Commissioner Andrew Fletcher, with all members voting in favor.
Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation by Captain Mike Lamb of the Asheville Police Department (APD) on downtown public safety. Captain Lamb reported that violent crime is at its highest level in the last five years and noted that low staffing has led to underreporting, as the department is not responding to all incidents. He stated that the department is experiencing a 39% reduction in staffing, with only 147 officers available to work out of an allotted 238. Captain Lamb attributed officer attrition since 2020 to compensation issues and a lack of community and political support.
The commission also discussed the Design Review Committee (DRC) and its recent review of the 72 Broadway hotel project. The conversation focused on the tension between subjective aesthetic reviews and objective standards. Commissioner Robin Raines expressed that the current process feels stressful and that the committee’s purview is unclear. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher questioned whether seeking objectivity in design standards through the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) is feasible, noting that City Council previously exerted more pressure on applicants than the DRC does. Ruth Summers suggested that the DRC or the Downtown Commission should have the authority to prevent high-rise buildings from overshadowing historic structures on specific streets.
Other topics included updates from the Asheville Downtown Association (ADA) on upcoming events, a pedestrian walkability study, and a candidate forum. Staff provided updates on homeless initiatives, including the city budget and consultant work by the National Alliance to End Homelessness, as well as progress on PAX Square Plaza, AVL Share Space, and stormwater improvements. The commission also discussed logistics for returning to in-person meetings, with Chair Bryan Moffitt expressing a preference for an 8:30 AM start time while acknowledging the benefits of virtual attendance.
Follow-ups
Several staff and members agreed to specific follow-up actions:
- APD Staffing Data: Captain Lamb agreed to have Human Resources gather information comparing APD staffing to other city departments.
- Officer Incentives: Captain Lamb agreed to find out the timeline for officer retention and hiring bonuses.
- Design Guidelines: Todd Oclicchini, Planning and Urban Design Director, offered to present on the roles and responsibilities of the DRC and the Downtown Commission at an upcoming meeting.
- Walkability Study: Megan Rogers of the ADA agreed to reach out with more information regarding the September walkability study and volunteer recruitment.
- DRC Guidelines: Commissioner Bryan Moffitt stated he will start putting together materials for a DRC guideline discussion for the September meeting.
Impact
This meeting highlighted significant concerns regarding public safety resources in the downtown area, specifically the impact of police staffing shortages on crime response and reporting. Additionally, the debate over the Design Review Committee’s authority and standards suggests ongoing scrutiny of how new developments, such as the 72 Broadway hotel, are evaluated for their impact on the historic character of the downtown district.
Meeting Video & Transcript