Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
July 7, 2022 at 9:30 AM
- 2 h 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) met on July 7, 2022, to review housing data, discuss federal funding constraints, and provide feedback on upcoming development projects. The agenda included updates on the city’s affordable housing calculator, the Thrive Asheville equity project, and the reorganization of the Community Development department. The committee also reviewed applications for open board seats and discussed upcoming community events, including a housing fair scheduled for September 10.
Key Decisions The committee’s primary formal action was the approval of the minutes from the May 5, 2022 meeting; a motion was made and seconded, and the Chair proceeded to the next item, indicating approval. No other formal votes were taken during the session. Specifically, no vote was held to change the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) policy regarding manufactured homes, nor was a vote taken on the Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) project on Longshaw Road or the 319 Biltmore Avenue development. The meeting was adjourned by the Chair without objection.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting focused on the feasibility of using CDBG funds to repair mobile homes not on permanent foundations. Staff clarified that HUD guidance currently prohibits using these funds for units not on a permanent foundation, though the installation of a permanent foundation might be eligible if clarified by HUD. Committee member David Bartholomew noted that moving a home or installing a foundation is often more expensive than the home itself, emphasizing the need for federal assistance. The committee agreed to continue investigating local funding alternatives and the costs associated with foundation installation.
Regarding the Longshaw Road LUIG project, which includes 186 units, Committee member Brian Methvin expressed concern about a "two-tier standard" where affordable units might have inferior materials compared to market-rate units. Staff member Sasha Vertunsky responded that policy revisions could include language prohibiting inferior finishes or segregation by affordability. On the 319 Biltmore Avenue project, Chair Andy Barnett noted surprise at the low unit count compared to previous estimates of 300-400 units, while Brian Methvin suggested that relaxing affordability percentage constraints might allow the project to deliver more housing units for the target population.
The committee also discussed a new "work plan" pilot process presented by Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood, which links City Council strategic priorities to advisory boards. Chair Andy Barnett raised concerns that this top-down approach might limit the committee's role as a citizen input platform, asking how community members would impact agenda setting. Rachel Wood responded that the committee could use its quarterly updates to dialogue with the City Council on specific areas not covered in the Council’s work plan.
Community Input One public commenter, representing a community school in Buncombe County, spoke during the public comment period. The commenter expressed appreciation for the committee’s discussions on ensuring new housing units accommodate families with children and suggested that the next step should be to translate this conversation into policy practice. Specifically, the commenter recommended reviewing the LUIG policy and examining how remaining bond dollars are spent to ensure units are appropriate in bedroom count and stability for families. The Chair responded with a "thank you," and no other members or staff provided specific replies to the commenter’s suggestions.
Follow-ups Several staff members and committee members agreed to specific follow-up actions. Rachel Wood stated she will present the draft Housing and Community Development (HCD) work plan to the HCD Committee on July 19 and plans to return to AHAC in August with specific assignments for the AHAC work plan. David Bartholomew agreed to review the HUD memo and state law implications regarding manufactured homes and share findings via email. Staff member Sasha Vertunsky agreed to add bullet points to the action agenda regarding CDBG eligibility for manufactured homes and to include committee comments on unit mix and quality standards in her staff report to City Council. Additionally, staff member Christina and Committee member Paul Heathman agreed to coordinate on a monthly update schedule for the affordable housing calculator’s mortgage rate data.
Impact These discussions highlight the ongoing tension between federal funding restrictions and local housing needs, particularly for residents in manufactured housing who may face prohibitive costs for permanent foundations. The committee’s feedback on the Longshaw Road and 319 Biltmore Avenue projects will inform final City Council decisions, potentially influencing the quality and density of new affordable housing stock. Furthermore, the implementation of the new work plan pilot aims to better align advisory board efforts with City Council strategic priorities, while the upcoming release of the 2022 housing street release and the September 10 housing fair will provide residents with updated information on affordable housing locations and resources.
Meeting Video & Transcript