Public Safety Committee
June 28, 2022 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 22 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Public Safety Committee Meeting Recap: June 28, 2022
The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee met on June 28, 2022, to discuss community safety strategies, gun violence prevention, and the development of annual work plans for City Council committees. The only formal action taken during the meeting was the approval of the minutes from April, which was approved following a motion, second, and roll call vote. No other formal votes or policy adoptions occurred, as the remainder of the agenda consisted of informational presentations and strategic discussions.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a presentation by Tiffany Hannah Cho, Director of Buncombe County Justice Services, regarding the Justice Resource Advisory Council’s initiatives. Funded in part by the MacArthur Foundation’s Safety and Justice Challenge, the presentation highlighted data showing disproportionate impacts on Black residents in Asheville and Buncombe County. Cho outlined a two-phase approach involving a pilot program with community-based organizations and the development of a comprehensive safety plan. The county is leaning toward implementing the CASM (Community Action for Safety and Mobility) violence interruption model due to its intergenerational focus. Cho emphasized that the work requires a coordinated response rather than operating in a vacuum, citing successful coordination efforts in Buncombe County regarding domestic violence.
Community-based organizations provided updates on their respective roles in gun violence prevention. Keenan Lake of My Daddy Taught Me That discussed the critical need for safe spaces for youth in neighborhoods such as Hillcrest, Klondike, and Pisgah View, noting that current facilities are insufficient. He stated, "Asheville needs that [a safe space for youth] yesterday... Our kids have nowhere to go." Jackie Latech of the SPARC Foundation outlined a three-tiered strategy focusing on youth development, immediate violence interruption, and long-term reentry. Latech stressed that short-term funding cycles hinder trust-building, stating, "We need to be ensured that this [funding] is going to carry forward far into our future. Otherwise, we're not going to get those outcomes."
Council members engaged in a discussion regarding the necessity of dedicated, safe spaces and long-term funding mechanisms. Vice Mayor Shanika Smith reflected on the need to build trust, stating, "I do believe that, collectively, we dropped the ball... if trust saves lives, then how do we build the trust?" Councilwoman Kim Roney summarized the discussion as a need for spaces that provide a sense of belonging and funding that offers longevity rather than recurring pilot cycles. City Manager Deborah Campbell noted that the city is exploring potential spaces and is re-imagining public safety to address the needs of the whole person, including assessing financial capability for debt to address competing needs like sidewalks and drainage.
During end-of-meeting public comment, a resident spoke about the need for a comprehensive Asheville public safety strategy. The commenter referenced the MacArthur Safety and Justice Challenge funding and data from the APD Simplicity database, citing disturbing trends in crime, missing persons, and runaways at public housing sites. They expressed interest in the work of community organizations like My Daddy Taught Me That and urged for faster outcomes than a 3-4 year timeline. Members did not respond to this specific public comment before the meeting was adjourned.
Several follow-up actions were explicitly agreed to by staff and members. Tiffany Hannah Cho agreed to provide more specific information on the role of the housing authority in testing strategies and to share details on the CASM model and Durham’s HEART program for comparison. Councilwoman Roney requested that staff look into including a recommendation for a city partnership in a youth facility, potentially via bond programming, involving partners such as Dogwood Health Trust and the Tourism Development Authority. Additionally, Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager, agreed to include a request for a climate justice initiative and neighborhood resiliency report in the Public Safety Committee’s work plan. Councilwoman Roney also suggested that the team of presenters return to the committee once they have a next step or data set to review, a proposal Vice Mayor Smith agreed to.
The committee also reviewed a framework for developing annual work plans for all City Council committees, presented by Assistant City Manager Rachel Wood. The goal is to align committee activities, staff work, and advisory board assignments with the City Council’s annual strategic priorities. The Housing and Community Development Committee will pilot this process first, with all committees expected to have finalized work plans by October. City Manager Campbell confirmed that staff are working on a work program for public safety, finance, and HR to address future capital and funding needs, and stated that the city may have more ideas about a path forward for youth programming space in the next couple of months.
Meeting Video & Transcript