Reparations Commission (please read description below)
June 27, 2022 at 6:44 PM
- 1 h 15 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On June 27, 2022, the City of Asheville Reparations Commission convened to discuss the operational framework for its ongoing work, specifically focusing on the transition from research to the development of recommendations. The meeting centered on the project’s timeline, key deliverables for the current phase, and strategies for community engagement.
Key Decisions and Discussions
The primary discussion involved the project’s timeline and activities. Staff outlined that the commission has completed two of the nine planned activities and is currently in Activity 3: Racial Equity Reparations and Impact Focus Area Research, which is scheduled to last seven months. To avoid delays, Activity 4: Development of Recommendations will run in parallel with Activity 3. Staff emphasized that the total project duration is estimated at roughly 24 months, but the timeline is controlled by the commission to ensure quality over artificial deadlines. A staff member stated, "We do want to make sure that we are not compromising quality over artificial deadlines. We want to make sure that we're doing it right. And so at any point you feel that there needs to be adjustments in this timeline, this is controlled by the commission."
Staff identified three primary deliverables for the current research phase: a comprehensive document establishing a baseline understanding of reparations, a list of eligible types of redress (such as direct payments or programmatic investments), and eligibility criteria. Regarding the development of recommendations, staff advised that they should be prioritized rather than submitted individually to ensure coherence. Key considerations for each recommendation include implementation risks, community capacity issues, and potential fiscal agents. Staff noted that recommendations may be categorized as "Global" (addressing disparities across multiple areas) or "Immediate" (with an expected implementation timeframe within six months, with October noted as a key milestone).
Regarding the budget, staff reported that the Buncombe County FY23 budget was passed the previous week. The current balance was reported as $2,235,000, with expenses to date at $365,000. Future appropriations are anticipated at approximately $500,000 per year as funding becomes available.
A motion was made to refer a document to a committee to develop a proposal, as a member noted the group was "not ready" to vote on current proposals. The Chair stated, "Consider it the next meeting," indicating that voting on the specific proposals would be deferred to allow for further feedback. No vote was recorded in the transcript for this motion.
Community Input
During public comment, a resident speaking on behalf of youth emphasized that young people would benefit from the commission’s work and urged the body to "stick to what you're charged to," noting that the issue has a "250-year head start." The commenter argued that while there are other ways to deal with current injustices, reparations are a distinct charge. The Chair responded by closing public comment and moving to the agenda item regarding the project framework.
Another public commenter expressed confusion regarding how information is shared with the community, stating they had sent emails on the day of the meeting to clarify information dissemination. A staff member responded by explaining that the commission’s approach to community engagement is "slightly different" than traditional city or county methods. The staff member stated, "We do direct door-to-door. We want to do community events... And part of that is definitely getting the kids involved, getting the buzz on the street, getting this whole town talking about reparations and really engaging with it." The staff member added that this engagement would help ensure a "huge group of people" supports the final recommendations.
Follow-ups
The Chair directed that the document be sent to a committee to come back with a proposal, with the understanding that voting would occur at the next meeting. Staff reminded workgroups to appoint a spokesperson and a recorder for their activities. Additionally, staff asked commission members to suggest locations for hosting community events, noting that restrictions on the board do not apply to the commission. Staff also indicated they would look into formalizing community submissions via a survey, potentially one per workgroup or a single commission-wide survey to avoid burdening residents.
Impact
This meeting established the procedural path for the commission to move from research to actionable recommendations. By defining the parallel execution of research and recommendation development, the commission aims to maintain a 24-month timeline while prioritizing the quality of its work. The focus on direct community engagement, including door-to-door outreach and events, signals an intent to build broad support for the final recommendations, which may face legal challenges. Staff noted that demonstrating the harm and related policies that caused it is critical when putting forward these recommendations.
Meeting Video & Transcript