Audit Committee
June 16, 2022 at 3:06 PM
- 1 h 21 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville Audit Committee convened on June 16, 2022, for an informational meeting focused on financial reporting, internal audit capabilities, and organizational performance. The session addressed three primary agenda items: the year-end financial close and external audit status, updates on the internal audit program, and an introduction to the Office of Data and Performance (ODAP). No formal motions were made, and no votes were taken during the meeting.
Financial Reporting and Lease Accounting
Staff provided an update on the timeline for closing the fiscal year and the implementation of new lease accounting standards under GASB 87. During the discussion, Finance staff committed to double-checking with the Parks and Recreation department to ensure that no in-kind leases or property usage agreements were missed in the lease population review. This step is intended to verify the completeness of the city’s lease records as part of the external audit preparation.
Internal Audit Program and Risk Assessment
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the internal audit program, specifically the ongoing recruitment for a vacant internal auditor position. Tony McDowell, Director of Finance, acknowledged the difficulty in filling the role, noting that the city had trouble finding qualified candidates and that current salary levels may create challenges in a competitive job market. He stated that the city will evaluate applications in July and, if the position remains vacant after interviews, will reassess the salary or explore other options for moving the program forward.
Andrew Emory, a member of the Audit Committee, expressed concern that the prolonged vacancy is causing a loss of institutional knowledge, stating, "My worry is that the institutional knowledge without having someone in a day-to-day position there in the city is diminishing instead of increasing. So to me that implies additional risk." Emory also noted that outsourcing the function entirely may not be the "highest and best use of the money" compared to hiring in-house.
In response to a member’s suggestion, McDowell stated that he and Finance staff will reach out to Buncombe County in the next couple of weeks to discuss their internal audit program and risk ranking methods. Additionally, McDowell confirmed that a Request for Proposals (RFP) for an organizational risk assessment went live recently with a deadline of July 13. The city hopes to award the contract in early Fiscal Year 23 and complete the assessment within six months of award.
Office of Data and Performance Introduction
Representatives from the Office of Data and Performance (ODAP) introduced their team, mission, and current projects, which include data governance, community engagement, and performance management frameworks. Eric Jackson, ODAP Manager, emphasized the office’s role in changing organizational culture, stating, "We don't see ourselves as kind of an internal service function... Our role is really to enable others to change the way that they're working." He highlighted the importance of collaboration, noting, "There's nothing we do that doesn't have us in a close partnership with our communications... finance... equity department..."
Committee Structure Discussion
The meeting also included a discussion regarding the future of the Audit Committee in the context of the city’s boards and commissions restructuring proposal. One member asked for clarification, stating, "It’s my understanding that the audit committee does not continue as a part of that." Another member clarified that the restructuring is still a proposal and that specifics regarding the Audit Committee have not been determined, inviting stakeholders to get involved with the working group. The Chair responded to the concern by stating, "I can tell you the audit committee is not necessarily going away we just have this bump in the road as far as getting you know our um position filled."
Follow-Ups and Next Steps
The committee agreed to reconvene in late August or early September, anticipated for the third Thursday of the month, to review the RFP responses and the status of the internal audit recruitment. Staff committed to the specific actions outlined above, including the evaluation of internal auditor applications in July, the outreach to Buncombe County, and the verification of lease records with Parks and Recreation. There were no public comments during the meeting.
Meeting Video & Transcript