Noise Advisory Board
June 13, 2022 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 11 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Noise Advisory Board Meeting Recap: June 13, 2022
The City of Asheville’s Noise Advisory Board held a virtual meeting on June 13, 2022, to review recent noise complaint data, discuss draft mitigation guidelines, and address changes to the board’s operational structure. The session included the approval of previous minutes, a staff report on data collection issues, and discussions regarding the establishment of new working groups to address specific noise concerns.
Key Decisions The board voted to approve the minutes from the May 9, 2022 meeting. A motion was made and seconded, followed by a roll call vote in which Charles Beck, Rick Freeman, and the Chair voted in favor, resulting in the approval of the minutes. The board also agreed to transition from a monthly to a quarterly meeting schedule, with the next full board meeting set for September 12, 2022. Additionally, the board established two new working groups: one focused on decibel levels, comprising Rick Freeman and Jeffrey Santiago, and another focused on sound mitigation and the "Good Neighbor" policy, comprising Jessica Tomasin, Carmelo Papalonio, and tentatively Jeffrey Santiago, pending his availability.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to reviewing a draft document titled "Good Neighbor Sound Mitigation Tips." Board members debated specific wording in the draft, particularly a statement suggesting that residents should expect a certain level of noise in a dense city. Rick Freeman expressed concern that this language might discourage residents from filing valid complaints, stating that it would create a "potential negative barrier" for citizens trying to understand their rights. In response, Carmelo Papalonio clarified that the intent was to provide accessible, non-technical guidance to encourage neighborly dialogue, not to discourage valid complaints. Jessica Tomasin, serving as Chair, further clarified that the document was intended as an introductory resource for proactive behavior and was not meant to be a barrier to enforcement.
Staff also presented data regarding noise complaints from industrial and commercial sources, excluding hospitality venues. A staff member noted that tracking these complaints is difficult because sources are often random, such as lawn equipment, and complainants may not know the exact location of the noise. The staff highlighted a successful case where they located a source on Riverside Drive after weeks of investigation based on a complainant’s pattern-keeping. Additionally, staff reported a technical issue with the online complaint form (JotForm) where user addresses were not being captured correctly, leading to approximately 33% of complaint records lacking address or phone number data.
During the meeting, board member Charles Beck announced his resignation from the Noise Advisory Board. He stated that this would be his last meeting because he had sold his condo and was leaving Asheville. Beck added that he did not see a successful resolution to noise issues in the next 12–18 months and felt that City Council needed to take a stronger stance on decibel limits.
Follow-ups Staff confirmed that a work order has been placed with IT to investigate the JotForm address capture issue. Rick Freeman suggested that the "Good Neighbor" document be audited by the City’s Communications and Public Engagement (CAPE) team before publication to ensure the messaging aligns with city standards, and the Chair agreed to bring the document to CAPE for review. Rick Freeman and Jeffrey Santiago will meet offline to determine the best method to assess citizen impact regarding decibel levels, with plans to report back to the full board in September. Jessica Tomasin, Carmelo Papalonio, and potentially Jeffrey Santiago will continue refining the "Good Neighbor" document and explore ways to disseminate the information. Staff member Haley Mahoney committed to determining the process for replacing the resigning board member and will contact board members with the answer by the end of the week. Ben Woody, Assistant City Manager, offered staff resources to support the working groups, including providing decibel meters if needed.
Impact This meeting marks a shift in the Noise Advisory Board’s operations, moving to a quarterly schedule to allow for more data accumulation to identify trends. The establishment of specific working groups aims to address the complexity of industrial noise and the need for clear, non-technical guidance for residents. The resignation of a board member and the identified data collection errors highlight ongoing challenges in accurately tracking and addressing noise complaints, which the board intends to address through the newly formed working groups and IT fixes.
Meeting Video & Transcript