Urban Forestry Commission
June 7, 2022 at 1:00 PM
- 2 h 12 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Urban Forestry Commission Meeting Recap: June 7, 2022
The Urban Forestry Commission of the City of Asheville held a virtual meeting on June 7, 2022, focusing on the intersection of urban forestry, stormwater management, and budget advocacy. The agenda featured two guest presentations: Phyllis Stiles, founder of Bee City USA, discussed the critical role of trees in supporting pollinator habitats, while Renee Fortner, Watershed Resources Manager at River Link, presented on the Central Asheville Watershed Restoration Plan and green infrastructure solutions for stormwater runoff. The Commission also reviewed staff reports, working group updates, and proposed changes to its own Rules and Procedures.
Key Decisions and Votes The Commission approved the minutes from the previous meeting via a roll call vote. Dawn Chavez, Ed Macy, Sharon (TRC Representative), Cecil Bothwell, and Chair Amy Smith voted "Aye," while Karen Deon abstained. The Commission also voted to approve updated Rules and Procedures, which included changing deferral and revival periods from 100 days to "within two regularly scheduled meetings" and correcting typos in Articles 5A and 6B. Dawn Chavez, Ed Macy, Sharon, Zoe Hoyle, Cecil Bothwell, and Chair Amy Smith voted "Aye" in favor of these amendments. Additionally, the Commission voted to postpone a discussion regarding quorum and public discourse rules to a future meeting to allow for adequate review, with the same six members voting "Aye." The meeting was adjourned unanimously.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to advocating for the creation of a full-time Urban Forester position and funding for the Urban Forest Master Plan. Dawn Chavez expressed frustration with the City’s lack of dedicated staff, stating, "I'm tired of this... It is way beyond time that we had an urban forester on staff in the city." Ed Macy supported this view, noting that volunteers are currently performing work that should be handled by the city, which suggests a lack of technical expertise in-house. Sharon, the TRC Representative, argued that the city is failing to meet its own requirements by keeping work in-house where it is "actually leaking." Kim Roney, the Asheville City Council Liaison, urged the Commission to be "firm and fair and clear" with City Council that the position is overdue.
The Commission also addressed the scope of its advocacy regarding jurisdictional boundaries, specifically concerning tree planting at schools. Dawn Chavez and Cecil Bothwell advised against the Commission organizing direct planting projects on school properties, as these fall under Buncombe County jurisdiction. Chair Amy Smith clarified that the Commission’s role is advisory to City Council on city projects, not operational for county properties. The group discussed working with advocacy groups like GreenWorks and the Tree Protection Task Force to initiate discussions with the county, rather than creating a new task force. Cecil Bothwell also expressed strong criticism of the 12-year delay in updating the city’s tree planting list, calling it "absolutely insane."
Follow-ups Several members and staff agreed to specific actions following the meeting. Dawn Chavez and Zoe Hoyle stated they will attend the City Council budget public hearing on June 14 to advocate for Urban Forester funding. Chair Amy Smith agreed to start a communication thread with members who can attend to coordinate talking points. Phyllis Stiles agreed to include a point about the necessity of an Urban Forester for maintaining Bee City status during her June 14 presentation. Regarding the Rules and Procedures, Chair Amy Smith and staff assistant Haley Mahoney will finalize the draft incorporating the approved changes. Nancy Watford, Stormwater Supervisor, stated she will ask Chris Collins how to update the species list in the MuniCode system, while Sharon stated she will double-check the links to ensure the old list is removed. Chair Amy Smith also stated she has reached out to Ben Woody, Assistant City Manager, to initiate a separate discussion regarding Duke Energy’s role in tree trimming.
Impact on Residents These discussions highlight the Commission’s push to secure dedicated resources for maintaining Asheville’s tree canopy, which is vital for stormwater management, air quality, and climate resilience. The approval of updated Rules and Procedures aims to streamline the Commission’s operations, while the postponement of quorum discussions allows for further review. The focus on the June 14 City Council budget hearing underscores the urgency of securing funding for professional urban forestry management, a role currently filled by volunteers and part-time staff.
Meeting Video & Transcript