Skip to main content

Housing & Community Development Committee

April 27, 2022 at 10:00 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Next: Feb 8, 2023 meeting
  • 51 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Housing and Community Development Committee Recap: April 27, 2022

The City of Asheville’s Housing and Community Development Committee met on April 27, 2022, to review four primary agenda items: the approval of previous minutes, a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIGI) application, a request for affordable housing bond funds, and input from the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC). The committee took action on all three decision items, with two resulting in unanimous recommendations to the full City Council and one resulting in a split vote.

Key Decisions The committee unanimously voted to approve the action minutes from the previous meeting. Regarding the Hilliard Flats project, the committee voted 2-1 to recommend that the City Council approve the LUIGI application for 217 Hilliard Avenue. Chair Sage Turner and Councilwoman Antoinette Mosley voted in favor, while Vice Mayor Shanika Smith voted against. For the Deep Review project, the committee unanimously voted to recommend that the City Council authorize the City Manager to negotiate a grant agreement with the Housing Authority for $1.2 million in affordable housing bond funds.

Discussion Highlights During the review of the Hilliard Flats application, which proposes 80 micro-housing units with 16 affordable for 20 years, Vice Mayor Smith expressed opposition, stating, "I don’t see how this is really serving the community and folks who frequent that area often who have so many needs... It’s a no for me." In contrast, Councilwoman Mosley voiced support, noting, "I’m thrilled to see more affordable units coming to downtown... I get a little worried about all the activity on Hilliard Avenue but it’s a very walkable urban place."

On the Deep Review item, Chair Turner raised concerns about the funding structure, asking, "I’m concerned about the Buncombe County and are we all in at the same amount." Staff member Sasha Bratinski responded by explaining the subsidy level, noting, "1.2 million is about $14,600 per unit, which is you know, pretty low subsidy per unit."

The final agenda item involved a discussion with AHAC leadership regarding improved communication channels. AHAC Chair Barry Bialik expressed frustration with the current lack of formal communication, stating, "We really wanted to just kind of discuss how we can have better communication flow... We kind of never know where they go." City Manager Deborah Campbell responded by suggesting that the AHAC’s request for better integration with council committees would be added to the list of considerations for the ongoing "boards and commissions" restructuring process. Vice Mayor Smith cautioned against giving preferential treatment to one group, stating, "We have to kind of weigh that out... I don’t want to get into the conversation about who should [be] over another because all issues are issues that we need to look at equitably."

Follow-ups Chair Sage Turner agreed to meet informally with AHAC members to discuss their top priorities and improve communication flow. She stated, "I’m happy to have a standing meeting with you if it helps," and asked AHAC to send calendar invites for these meetings. Additionally, staff indicated that the City Attorney and planning staff would meet with the developer later that day to craft the zoning conditions for the Deep Review project, specifically regarding the duration of affordability, before the item goes to full Council on May 10.

Impact These decisions determine the next steps for two significant housing projects in Asheville. The Hilliard Flats project, if approved by the full Council, will add 80 micro-housing units to the downtown area, including 16 units designated as affordable for 20 years. The Deep Review project will receive $1.2 million in bond funds to support its development, a subsidy calculated at approximately $14,600 per unit. Furthermore, the committee’s engagement with the AHAC aims to establish more consistent communication between the advisory body and the council, which will be considered as part of a broader review of city boards and commissions.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches