Noise Advisory Board
April 11, 2022 at 1:00 PM
- 56 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The City of Asheville’s Noise Advisory Board held a virtual meeting on April 11, 2022. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of recent noise complaint data, a status update on the city’s restructuring of boards and commissions, and a detailed presentation on the enforcement of commercial waste hauler noise regulations.
Key Decisions The board’s only formal vote was to approve the minutes from the March 14, 2022 meeting. A motion was made and seconded, followed by a roll call vote in which all three voting members present voted "Yes," resulting in the approval of the minutes. Regarding the city’s ongoing restructuring of boards and commissions, no vote was taken. Instead, a board member recommended that the board hold off on voting on the restructuring resolution until the city completes the next stage of the pilot process, specifically the formation of working groups. The Chair agreed to wait and see how the process develops.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented a review of noise complaint data from the previous month, highlighting trends in residential, business, and vehicle noise. A staff member noted a reduction in chronic complainants and chronic complaints from known "noisemakers," but identified a new trend involving individuals the department had never spoken to before. Board Member Rick Freeman expressed concern regarding the board's mission, stating, "If ultimately we’re going to get 40 to 50 [complaints] a month and it’s going to go that way forever, then something that we’re doing is not achieving the mission... The numbers have to come down or we don’t achieve our goals."
The board also discussed the enforcement of the commercial waste hauler component of the noise ordinance. Staff member Chris Collins explained the enforcement philosophy, noting, "We did do that for the first six months... So now what we will do is... courtesy email, written warning and citation." He added, "The goal here has always been, the philosophy has always been to work with people for voluntary compliance." Regarding the board restructuring, Rick Freeman stated, "I think my recommendation would be for people who are intimately involved in what they’re recommending, feels like it’s worth giving the city a chance to move on to the next stage that we just hold on to this document until we get through that part."
Community Input There were no public comments at this meeting. Staff confirmed that no comments were received prior to the meeting and no individuals called in to speak.
Follow-ups Staff provided several updates on immediate actions. They confirmed that meetings with Waste Pro had already occurred and that meetings with two other waste haulers were scheduled for the following week, one in person and one via video conference. Additionally, staff confirmed that they would conduct noise measurement readings at three specific bar and restaurant locations that weekend to ensure compliance with decibel levels. When asked if outreach to multifamily property managers was reducing chronic noise complaints, a staff member stated that it would take "quite a bit of staff time" to analyze the data to determine if specific complexes are seeing a reduction, acknowledging the need to look at the details but not committing to a specific deadline.
Impact This meeting focused on the board's ongoing efforts to manage noise complaints and adapt to the city’s administrative changes. The decision to delay voting on the board restructuring allows the board to observe the city’s working group process before making a final determination on its future role. The shift in waste hauler enforcement toward a tiered system of courtesy emails, written warnings, and citations reflects a continued emphasis on voluntary compliance. Furthermore, the data presented indicates a changing landscape in noise complaints, with a decrease in repeat offenders but an increase in complaints from new sources, which the board and staff will continue to monitor.
Meeting Video & Transcript