Neighborhood Advisory Committee
February 28, 2022 at 5:00 PM
- 1 h 12 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The Neighborhood Advisory Committee (NAC) of the City of Asheville held a virtual meeting on February 28, 2022. The agenda covered administrative updates, a city-wide initiative to restructure boards and commissions, neighborhood grant progress, and the committee’s annual report to City Council.
Key Decisions
The committee took three formal votes, all of which were unanimous. First, the committee approved the minutes from the January 24, 2022, meeting. Second, the committee elected Sharon Sumrall as Vice Chair. Third, the committee adopted the annual report to be sent to City Council. Regarding the role of NAC liaison to the Multimodal Transportation Commission, no formal vote was taken because the role is not currently mandated by bylaws. However, Elizabeth Likus Worley volunteered to serve as the liaison for the current year, and Chair Bobbette Kilgore Mays committed to attending some meetings to gather information. The committee agreed to review the bylaws to clarify if this role should be formalized. No decision was made to adopt or reject the proposed boards and commissions restructuring pilot; the committee agreed to continue monitoring the process.
Discussion Highlights
A significant portion of the meeting focused on a city-wide pilot program to restructure boards and commissions, which proposes reducing the number of advisory boards and creating time-limited "working groups." Staff clarified that while City Council has returned to in-person meetings, boards and commissions are continuing to meet virtually to maintain accessibility for residents with barriers to participation. Staff emphasized that the restructuring goal is to make the process "more strategic, more efficient, and more inclusive," and clarified that no final decision has been made yet.
Members raised concerns regarding the proposed working groups. J.P. Chalaka expressed concern about the lack of vetting and conflict of interest mitigation for self-selected members, stating, "this is an opportunity for us to really mess this up." Sharon Sumrall expressed alarm at the proposal to reduce boards and commissions from 20 to 4, noting, "I have a lot of issues and I have spoken up a lot on it... I think it will impact NAC for sure." She requested a subcommittee or working group to discuss the issue further so NAC could develop a consensus opinion.
Other discussions included an update on neighborhood grants, where staff noted that agreements are being signed and at least one organization has received funds to begin their project. Chair Bobbette Kilgore Mays described the situation in the Shiloh neighborhood, stating, "Shiloh is probably... the last intact African-American neighborhood... So we're right in the middle of reparation, reappraisals, gentrification, redlining." Staff also reported that the search for a Neighborhood and Community Engagement Manager was unsuccessful and the position will be reopened.
Follow-ups
Staff member Dawa Hitch agreed to send the dates and times for upcoming community meetings regarding the boards and commissions restructuring to all committee members. Dawa Hitch also agreed to add a column to the neighborhood grants spreadsheet to specify the projects associated with each grant, reach out to the City Clerk’s office to get details on board training for the Chair and Vice Chair, pass along feedback regarding conflict of interest concerns about the working groups to the relevant city group, and send meeting information for the Multimodal Transportation Commission to Elizabeth Likus Worley and the Chair. Member Sharon Sumrall agreed to provide information on the Technical Review Committee (TRC) at the next meeting. Elizabeth Likus Worley agreed to serve as the liaison to the Multimodal Transportation Commission for the current year. Chair Bobbette Kilgore Mays agreed to attend some Multimodal Transportation Commission meetings to gather information and to meet with Dawa Hitch before future meetings to discuss the Vice Chair role.
Impact
The meeting addressed the immediate operational status of the committee, including the election of a Vice Chair and the adoption of the annual report to City Council. The discussion on the boards and commissions restructuring highlights ongoing city-wide efforts to modify how advisory bodies operate, with specific attention to how these changes may affect the NAC and its ability to represent neighborhood interests. The update on neighborhood grants indicates that funding is beginning to reach local organizations, while the discussion on the Shiloh neighborhood underscores the complex social and economic challenges facing specific communities within Asheville.
Meeting Video & Transcript