Multimodal Transportation Commission
February 23, 2022 at 3:00 PM
- 2 h 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Multimodal Transportation Commission Meeting Recap: February 23, 2022
The City of Asheville Multimodal Transportation Commission (MMTC) held a meeting on February 23, 2022, to address three primary agenda items: a request to close a right-of-way on Rear Clingman Avenue, a final update on the "Close the Gap" initiative for greenways and pedestrian infrastructure, and an update on the proposed Merriman Avenue lane conversion. The commission began by unanimously approving the agenda and the minutes from the January 26, 2022 meeting.
The commission voted unanimously to recommend that City Council deny the request by Delray Ventures to close a 175-foot alley associated with the "Avery Project" (formerly Patton II). Staff initially recommended approval based on the project’s conditional zoning; however, because City Council denied the Avery Project’s zoning application the previous evening, staff changed their recommendation to deny the closure. Staff explained that without a concrete development plan, the city could not ensure the alley would provide public benefits such as pedestrian access, utility placement, or off-street loading. A staff member from Transportation stated, "We as staff do not feel comfortable with closing this right away at this time, given the conditional zoning was not approved." Additionally, a staff member from Planning and Urban Design noted that alleys are valuable for keeping congestion off main streets by providing secondary access and loading opportunities.
Regarding the Greenway, ADA Transition, and Pedestrian Plan, the commission unanimously endorsed the "Top 10" list of Greenway projects presented by staff and consultants. Staff emphasized the importance of a public survey currently open regarding the plan, specifically noting that funding for ADA transitions is low and that it is critical to gauge public support for a dedicated transportation fund. Staff requested that commission members share the general public link for the survey with their networks and asked them to review detailed slides and send any specific questions via email.
The commission also addressed the Merriman Avenue 4-to-3 lane conversion, focusing on the scope of the project and strategies to counter public opposition. A motion was made, attributed to the BikePED Task Force via Commissioner Randy Warren, stating that bicycle and pedestrian facilities are essential to Merriman Avenue and that the conversion should extend the length of the street to provide safe and predictable facilities for all modes. The motion was amended to specify that while the lane conversion should occur to Chestnut Street, a treatment (improvements) should occur all the way to US-240. The amended motion passed unanimously. During the discussion, a commission member noted that project advisors were using 2045 traffic statistics that did not account for potential mode shifts, leading to predictions of increased backup near US-240. Commissioner Bill Loftis expressed a desire for a clearer timeline, stating, "I just love to see some sense of when this is gonna be realized... it would be really nice to have some vision of hey in the next five years we'll have this much done... I think a little bit of a reality check would be helpful."
No formal public comment period was held for the right-of-way or greenway items. For the Merriman Avenue item, while not a formal public comment session, commission members and staff discussed the intense public opposition to the project, including significant activity on social media and local news. A commission member warned that "nervous stakeholders might dominate the narrative after public input." In response, staff encouraged members to attend the public meeting scheduled for the following Monday to provide data-backed talking points, noting that the project website contains a "story map" with traffic volume, crash history, and congestion data to help counter misconceptions.
Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. The chair stated, "We'll definitely look at that kind of independent of this issue," acknowledging the commission's interest in revisiting the policy on unopened right-of-ways after a member asked why the city does not accept ownership of these areas to potentially sell them for revenue. Staff confirmed that a public meeting for the Merriman Avenue project would be held the following Monday, and several members indicated they would attend to represent the commission. Staff stated that after the public meeting, they would synthesize the input and report back to the commission, with a decision on the project expected by May. Due to time constraints, the remaining agenda items were deferred to the next meeting.
Meeting Video & Transcript