Noise Advisory Board
February 14, 2022 at 1:00 PM
- 1 h 59 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Noise Advisory Board Meeting Recap: February 14, 2022
The City of Asheville Noise Advisory Board convened on February 14, 2022, to review the implementation of the city’s new noise ordinance and address operational data challenges. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a staff report on complaint trends, the adoption of a board mission statement, and a presentation on proposed zoning amendments for outdoor performance venues.
Key Decisions The Board took two formal votes during the meeting. First, the minutes from the January 10, 2022 meeting were approved unanimously via roll call vote. Second, a draft mission statement for the Noise Advisory Board was also approved unanimously via roll call vote. The meeting was subsequently adjourned after the Chair asked for objections and hearing none. The next meeting is scheduled for March 14, 2022, with the location to be posted prior to that date.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented reports on noise complaint trends and proactive outreach to 34 private property management companies and venues. A staff member emphasized that the ordinance is not "flat" and varies significantly by context, such as trash collection versus music. Regarding the proposed zoning amendment for outdoor performance venues, staff clarified that existing businesses would retain nonconforming rights to continue operating, meaning the change would not affect current operations.
A significant portion of the discussion focused on the disconnect between source compliance and complainant impact. Board member Rick Freeman stated, "Without decibel readings when they're taken associated with the complaint, I don't think we can do our job... Either we're inadequately educating the public about what the standards are or the public is dissatisfied with the noise levels that the ordinance permits." He also expressed concern that current call data "doesn't tell me enough." In response to cases where sources are within decibel limits but residents are still significantly affected, a Board member suggested that taking measurements inside the complainant’s residence could provide valuable data to understand this issue.
Staff also addressed the challenge of correlating specific noise complaints with decibel measurements. A staff member noted, "I don't think it's hard to get you that information. It's just the correlation might be a little bit challenging." Regarding field work, Board member Corbin Harwood stated, "From my perspective, it was extremely helpful because I got to see not only where the noise complaint was coming from, but also what it sounded like... It really is helpful to have someone from the city come out... and have an honest conversation." Additionally, a staff member named Granye Miser stated, "We actually met face to face with all of them [34 private property management companies] in the past month... We're not trying to be punitive here. We're not looking for people to be evicted."
Follow-ups Several follow-up actions were agreed upon by staff members:
- Outdoor Performance Venues: Chris Collins, Assistant Director of Planning & Urban Design, agreed to investigate defining sound-attenuating walls more precisely, potentially based on decibel reduction rather than physical dimensions. He also agreed to consult the legal department on the feasibility of adding sound attenuation standards to new residential construction near existing venues.
- Data Visualization: Ben Woody, Assistant City Manager, indicated that a GIS mapping function (heat map) for noise complaints is being developed and is expected to be available within the next month.
- Decibel Data: Staff member Granye Miser agreed to look into providing decibel measurement data to the Board, potentially as a separate spreadsheet cross-referenced with complaint data. He stated that if specific times of day are identified as recurring issues, staff will schedule visits to capture accurate readings.
- Ordinance Effectiveness: Staff committed to bringing more data to the Board by the end of the summer to identify which components of the ordinance are effective and easy to enforce versus those that are challenging.
- Measurement Protocol: Staff acknowledged a Board suggestion to consider taking measurements of noise levels inside the complainant’s location, in addition to the source, as a data point to better understand complaints despite source compliance.
Impact This meeting highlighted the ongoing effort to refine the city's approach to noise enforcement. By committing to provide decibel data, develop complaint heat maps, and evaluate the effectiveness of specific ordinance components, staff aims to give the Board a clearer picture of where the current rules are working and where they are not. The discussion on measuring noise inside complainant homes addresses a specific gap in understanding why residents may still be affected even when noise sources are technically compliant with city limits.
Meeting Video & Transcript