Public Art & Cultural Commission
January 28, 2022 at 1:37 PM
- 3 h 2 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On January 28, 2022, the City of Asheville’s Public Art and Culture Commission held its annual retreat virtually. The session focused on the future of PAC Square, specifically the reimagining of the former Vance Monument site, and the commission’s role in its redevelopment. The agenda included administrative updates, a review of the draft annual report, and detailed discussions on the PAC Square Improvements Project, temporary art programs, and external models for public memory.
Key Decisions and Administrative Updates No formal votes or motions were taken during the retreat. Staff confirmed that the commission’s primary focus remains on public art, memorials, and monuments within the plaza. A Request for Proposals (RFP) is currently active to hire a project manager for the PAC Square Plaza Improvements Project, with submittals due on February 11. The commission will hold one more meeting before selecting a project manager. Additionally, staff noted that the Chair and Vice Chair terms are set to expire in June 2023, and annual elections for the commission will be held at the next meeting.
Discussion Highlights Staff outlined a two-step approach for the plaza: a concurrent "Call for Monument Art" to address the former Vance Monument site, and a longer-term comprehensive art program (9+ months) informed by a visioning process. The initial phase of the visioning project has a 6–9 month timeline. While the project will consider connectivity to the nearby YMCA and surrounding streets, a separate group is steering the broader public space planning.
Guest presenters provided context on public memory and engagement. Jay Miller, a philosopher and former Commission Chair, discussed monuments as "embodied narratives" and cited German "counter-monuments" as a model for dealing with dark history. Dr. Joseph Fox, Vice President of the MLK Association of Asheville & Buncombe County, emphasized equitable engagement, stating, "How do we build a process that brings in the folks that we normally don't hear from?" Dr. Kofi Boone, a Landscape Architecture Professor at NC State University, highlighted that "Monuments aren't permanent" and that new interventions must address suppressed histories through counter-narratives.
Commission members participated in a digital poll regarding the temporary art program, indicating a preference for art that is "compelling," "engaging," and "inclusive." Regarding criteria for the former Vance Monument site, members prioritized "content related to social and racial justice," "engages the community," and "quality of art." Members expressed strong support for providing city funding or stipends for artists. Commission member Pete Perez stated, "Timid and compromised ideas may not attract funding... boldness and clarity of vision will attract funding more than a lukewarm Laodicean approach." Commission member Shirley Walker Whitesides expressed hope that the space will be "functional so people can really use it for mental purposes, for aesthetics, for learning history, inclusion."
Community Input One public commenter submitted a pre-recorded comment urging the commission to consider the entire area as an entity, specifically noting the potential of the nearby YMCA as a cultural center that could complement the PAC Square area. Members did not respond to the comment.
Follow-ups Staff committed to several actions: reviewing project manager submittals due on February 11; working with Buncombe County Special Collections to create an index of historical materials regarding PAC Square; working with the community to create interpretation for existing dioramas previously housed in the Asheville Art Museum; and launching the "Call for Monument Art" concurrently with the PAC Square Visioning Project kickoff. Staff also committed to continuing to reiterate the project timeline and scope to the commission.
Members agreed to review the draft annual report and guiding ordinances offline before the next meeting. Members also agreed to consider who might serve as understudies for the Chair and Vice Chair roles leading up to the June 2023 elections. The Chair invited members to propose agenda items for the next meeting, with several members suggesting time for further educational discussions and community engagement strategies.
Impact This retreat established the strategic direction for the redevelopment of PAC Square, shifting focus toward iterative, low-cost, and high-impact interventions before major capital investment. By prioritizing public engagement and addressing the complex history of the site, including Indigenous and African American histories, the commission aims to create a space that is inclusive and reflective of the community. The upcoming selection of a project manager and the launch of the Call for Monument Art will determine the immediate next steps in transforming the former Vance Monument site into a functional and meaningful public space.
Meeting Video & Transcript