Historic Resources Commission
January 12, 2022 at 3:59 PM
- 3 h 3 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: January 12, 2022
The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) held a virtual meeting on January 12, 2022, to review preservation applications and discuss county planning initiatives. The agenda included four evidentiary hearings for properties within the Montford Historic District, a presentation on the Buncombe County Comprehensive Plan update, and updates on ongoing preservation projects. The Commission also approved the minutes from the previous meeting, with all voting members casting "Aye" votes.
Key Decisions and Votes The Commission unanimously approved the preliminary subdivision request for 124 Montford Avenue, which involves dividing a 0.67-acre lot into two smaller lots. No conditions were attached to this approval. For 162 West Chestnut Street, the Commission approved a Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) for the removal of a non-original addition and restoration of original features. This approval included two conditions: if construction reveals the pebble dash on front porch posts is original, work must cease and the material must be restored; and a landscape plan for replacement trees and shrubs must be submitted for staff review. The Commission also unanimously approved CAs for 144 Flint Street (roof modification and stair replacement) and 74 Cortland Avenue (demolition of a non-historic garage and construction of a new accessory dwelling unit). The approval for 74 Cortland Avenue was contingent on the applicant amending the application to include cedar shake siding on the gables and dormer, with final samples and revised door specifications to be submitted for staff review.
Comprehensive Plan and Preservation Discussions Jillian Phillips, Long Range Planning Manager for Buncombe County, presented on the Comprehensive Plan update, noting that in-person public input sessions are currently scheduled for the second, third, and fourth weeks of February, though staff are monitoring Omicron variant trends. The Commission participated in a facilitated exercise to identify top planning issues and "big ideas." The group voted to prioritize planning for sustainable infrastructure, growth/land use/housing/transportation, and education/economic mobility as top issues. Their top "big ideas" included allocating 1% of developer budgets for historic preservation, planning for affordable housing, and conducting a comprehensive inventory of historic resources.
Staff provided updates on several preservation initiatives. A draft report for the Burton Street architectural survey is expected by the end of the following week, after which staff plan to create a digital "pattern book" to help developers create thoughtful infill. The final revised draft of the African American Heritage Survey is also expected in the near future. Staff shared a success story regarding the preservation of the Cappadocia Church and a nearby house in the East End, which were saved from demolition through intervention by the Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County (PSABC) and are planned for reuse as affordable housing.
Community Input During the hearing for 162 West Chestnut Street, a public commenter stated they were "99.9% certain" the pebble dash on the front porch columns was not original and suggested the Commission grant the applicant discretion to remove or leave it. Chair Emily Kite discussed a logistical approach involving a condition for ongoing investigation, noting that if evidence showed the pebble dash was original, work would cease. Commissioner Gail Lazarus expressed happiness that the house was being restored and thanked the applicant for sharing historic research. During the Comprehensive Plan segment, public commenters asked about the impact of the pandemic on in-person sessions, how the plan affects funding, and state deadlines. Staff responded that the decision to shift to virtual formats rests with management and commissioners, that the plan sets broad policy priorities rather than specific line-item funding, and that while there is no strict state deadline, the priority is ensuring broad resident engagement.
Follow-Ups Staff member Alex agreed to follow up with applicants for 162 West Chestnut Street, 144 Flint Street, and 74 Cortland Avenue in the coming days to review required submissions, including landscape plans and material samples. Staff confirmed that Brenda Mills, the Equity and Inclusion Director, or a staff member from that department, will present on the reparations commission’s priorities and funding structure on a future agenda. Additionally, staff agreed to reach out to the state preservation staff listserv to identify examples of neighborhoods using facade protections or neighborhood conservation overlays, and to bring the Cappadocia Church preservation case to the monthly planning services group to ensure staff are informed about potential demolitions in underrepresented neighborhoods.
Impact on Residents These decisions directly affect the physical character of the Montford Historic District, ensuring that new construction and renovations align with historic preservation standards. The engagement with the Buncombe County Comprehensive Plan allows the Commission to influence long-term county policy regarding historic preservation and housing. The progress on the Burton Street survey and the African American Heritage Survey contributes to a better understanding of the city’s architectural and cultural heritage, which informs future preservation efforts and development guidelines.
Meeting Video & Transcript