Civil Service Board
January 6, 2022 at 2:29 PM
- 33 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview The City of Asheville Civil Service Board held its January 2022 meeting via a virtual platform on January 6, 2022. The board confirmed a quorum and addressed several agenda items, including the approval of previous minutes, the adoption of the 2022 meeting schedule, and an informational update on Fire Department promotional policies. The session concluded with an informal discussion regarding the logistics of upcoming quasi-judicial hearings.
Key Decisions The board took four formal votes during the meeting, all of which passed unanimously with a 5-0 tally. First, the board accepted the agenda as printed. Second, the board approved the minutes from the December 2, 2021 meeting, incorporating an amendment that corrected the record of a previous vote regarding the approval of the fifth member, changing the recorded vote from "four to one" to "five to zero." Third, the board adopted the regular meeting schedule for the 2022 calendar year, continuing to meet on the first Thursday of each month at 2:30 PM. Finally, the board voted to adjourn the meeting at 3:02 PM.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to an informational update from Chief Burnett regarding two administrative policy changes in the Fire Department’s promotional process. Chief Burnett explained that the goal of the changes is to ensure that a candidate is not removed from an eligibility list completely after a single opportunity, stating, "What we don't want to happen is just that candidate, just to have that one opportunity only... The goal is just to make sure that the person is not removed from the list completely."
The board also engaged in a detailed discussion on the feasibility of holding in-person versus virtual quasi-judicial hearings. One board member expressed a preference for in-person meetings, noting that it is often helpful to observe facial responses and body language in quasi-judicial situations. However, another board member argued that wearing masks in person negates the benefit of face-to-face contact, stating, "I would personally be against meeting in person while there's still a Buncombe County mask mandate." The City Attorney acknowledged the preference for in-person interaction but noted that the current virtual format "works, I think better than most of us thought that it would."
Additionally, the board coordinated dates for an upcoming grievance hearing. One board member noted that they were the only one with scheduling conflicts for the proposed days, expressing a desire not to delay the process. A staff member responded, "I'm not the one who goes and deliberates these things and takes forever. That's on y'all. So we'll figure it out."
Follow-ups The City Attorney agreed to explore legal barriers to holding in-person hearings, stating, "if you tell me to figure out how we can have an in-person hearing for these things, I'll explore it." He indicated he would discuss the matter with the City, noting that while current City policy is virtual, he was not aware of a specific ordinance prohibiting in-person meetings. The chair suggested that the City Attorney and another staff member speak before the next meeting to determine the options for the format of upcoming hearings. Additionally, a staff member agreed to send out the proposed dates for the grievance hearing to confirm availability with everyone.
Impact These decisions establish the operational framework for the Civil Service Board for the coming year, including its meeting cadence and the correction of the historical record regarding member approval. The update on Fire Department promotional policies clarifies how eligibility lists are managed, ensuring candidates retain their status on lists rather than being removed after a single attempt. The discussion on hearing formats highlights the board's ongoing evaluation of how to balance the benefits of in-person observation with current public health mandates, a factor that will influence the conduct of future quasi-judicial proceedings.
Meeting Video & Transcript