Skip to main content

Noise Advisory Board

December 13, 2021 at 3:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Next: Jan 10, 2022 meeting
  • 1 h 48 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Noise Advisory Board Meeting Recap: December 13, 2021

The City of Asheville’s Noise Advisory Board convened on December 13, 2021, to address noise ordinance implementation, board governance, and community concerns. The meeting included the approval of previous minutes, updates from working groups on decibel levels and sound mitigation, and discussions regarding board membership, meeting frequency, and enforcement strategies.

Key Decisions The board took several formal votes during the session. First, the board unanimously approved the minutes from the previous meeting held on June 13. Second, the board unanimously approved a set of survey questions designed to gather qualitative feedback from residents whose noise complaints were closed because decibel readings fell below legal limits. Third, the board unanimously approved a "Good Neighbor and Sound Mitigation Practices" document for posting on the city website to assist residents and businesses in managing noise. Finally, the board unanimously voted to remove Anup Krishnan from the board due to a lack of attendance.

Discussion Highlights The board discussed returning to a monthly meeting cycle and holding an annual retreat in October, though no formal vote was taken on the specific frequency for the coming year; staff indicated they would send a scheduling poll to determine the schedule. Regarding meeting format, the board debated whether to continue meeting remotely or return to in-person meetings. Jessica Tomasin expressed a preference for remote meetings to accommodate travel commitments, noting that in-person meetings would conflict with her schedule. Staff noted that the board must choose one format for the year and would check with the City Clerk and Attorney regarding the legality of hybrid meetings.

On enforcement, the board discussed forming a working group to address vehicle noise. Todd Justice suggested that the city could easily enforce a "no revving" ordinance, as law enforcement officers are the only ones authorized to stop motor vehicles. Additionally, the board discussed coordinating waste haulers in downtown alleys to reduce early morning noise. Rick Freeman stated that while this may be beyond the board's direct responsibility, the board could recommend to City Council that a working group be formed involving business leaders, community leaders, and waste haulers.

Community Input During public comment, a retired attorney expressed strong concern about intentional noise from automobiles and motorcycles, particularly groups parading downtown late at night. The commenter argued this is a legislative issue requiring strong enforcement, such as making it a traffic offense, and cited Greenville, NC, as a model. In response, the Chair stated, "Jeff, if you're still listening... I'm sure we'll be in touch with getting you potentially part of a working group."

Another public commenter, a resident of the Montford Hills neighborhood, expressed concern about a new music venue entering their area. The resident referenced a letter submitted to the board and requested attention to the issue, noting a desire to work with the venue to resolve it. The Chair replied, "Tom, yes, we received your letter... I can give you a little bit of information to tell you that I was CC'd on an email of... salvage station working with a team of outside engineers to work to mitigate the sound that as it travels to Montford... I'm going to ask them to make sure to reach out to the citizens and let them know the progress and the work that they're trying to do to address the issues that you and others have."

Follow-ups Staff member Haley Mahoney agreed to contact the City Clerk regarding the removal of Anup Krishnan and the posting of the vacancy. Mahoney also agreed to send a scheduling poll to board members this week to determine the time for the annual retreat and regular meetings. Additionally, Mahoney agreed to check with the City Clerk and Attorney regarding the legality of hybrid meetings. Staff members Haley Mahoney and Todd Justice agreed to finalize the council briefing slides by the 20th and share them with the board. Ben Woody agreed to quantify noise complaint data by census block group to address demographic concerns raised by Councilwoman Mosley. Rick Freeman agreed to draft a recommendation to City Council regarding the coordination of waste haulers in downtown alleys and to reach out to downtown residents to gauge interest. Freeman also agreed to share contact information for a downtown resident interested in the vehicle noise working group with Reb Haislip. Reb Haislip agreed to take the lead on the Vehicle Noise working group, pending further conversation with staff on scope. Jessica Tomasin agreed to ask the outside engineers working with the Salvage Station to reach out to Montford Hills residents regarding sound mitigation progress.

Impact These decisions and discussions impact residents by establishing clearer guidelines for noise management and addressing specific community concerns. The approval of the "Good Neighbor and Sound Mitigation Practices" document provides residents and businesses with resources to manage noise proactively. The removal of a board member and the discussion on meeting frequency and format affect how the board operates and engages with the community. The formation of a vehicle noise working group and the recommendation regarding waste haulers aim to address specific sources of noise that have been raised by residents, while the quantification of complaint data by census block group will help the city understand the geographic distribution of noise issues.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches