City Council P&Z Interviews – October 26, 2021
October 26, 2021 at 2:51 PM
- 1 h 3 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On October 26, 2021, the Asheville City Council held a virtual session to interview six candidates for a single vacancy on the Planning and Zoning (P&Z) Commission. The P&Z Commission is an advisory body that reviews Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) amendments and zoning proposals before making recommendations to the City Council. Each candidate was allotted a 10-minute slot to discuss their background, views on local development, and vision for the city’s future. No votes were taken during this interview session.
Key Discussions and Candidate Views The interviews focused on several critical themes, including affordable housing, sustainable development, and the balance between reviewing individual projects and updating broader policies. Candidates were asked by Council members about specific local developments and their approaches to zoning.
Regarding the 101 Charlotte Street development, Candidate Darren Prosser expressed concern that if Asheville loses its unique appeal due to high-density development, the city could be left with "vacant apartments and condos and hotels." Candidate Matthew Allen stated he "probably would have demurred and asked more questions" about the project, suggesting it should have better fit the neighborhood character. Candidate Nick Dugan discussed the need for affordable housing in urban infill sites and the evaluation of "carrots and sticks" in development policy. On the South Slope development, Candidate Sherry Kajiola expressed that she was "in awe" of the project, giving it a "big thumbs up" for the city’s involvement. Candidate Nick Dugan criticized the approval of the hotel at the former Renaissance Inn site, stating it was a "poor use of space" that did not benefit the community or recognize the land's history. Additionally, Candidate Kelsey Simmons stated that while she supports more housing, she wished the micro-housing development on Hilliard Avenue had prioritized "homeownership a little bit more."
Council members posed questions to the candidates regarding the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan, the balance between policy development and project review, and the intersection of urban design with public health and equity. Candidate Nick Dugan highlighted the inequity of expecting residents to have thousands of dollars for a vehicle to achieve social mobility. Candidate Matthew Allen expressed support for zoning flexibility to allow for more accessory dwelling units (ADUs) and multi-family structures.
Decisions and Next Steps No formal decisions or votes were taken during the interview session itself. However, Mayor Esther Manheimer explicitly stated that the City Council would vote to appoint a candidate to the Planning and Zoning Commission during the regular City Council meeting scheduled for 5:00 p.m. that same evening. No other specific follow-up actions, such as staff studies or committee referrals, were agreed upon during the interview session.
Impact on Residents This meeting serves as the final step in the selection process for a new member of the Planning and Zoning Commission, a body that plays a crucial role in shaping Asheville’s growth and land use policies. The candidates' responses provide insight into how the incoming commissioner might approach issues such as housing affordability, environmental stewardship, and the balance between development and community character. The outcome of the appointment vote will determine which of these perspectives will influence the Commission’s recommendations to the City Council.
Meeting Video & Transcript