Skip to main content

Finance Committee

October 26, 2021 at 1:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Aug 18 meeting
  • 1 h 31 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

The City of Asheville Finance Committee convened on October 26, 2021, to review the minutes from the previous meeting, receive updates from the Director of Finance, and discuss the Sanitation Division’s mid-year operational review. The agenda focused on financial transparency, grant processes, and the long-term sustainability of waste management services.

Key Decisions

The committee’s only formal action was the approval of the minutes from the previous meeting. A motion was made and seconded, and the vote was taken by roll call. Councilwoman Kilgore, Councilwoman Turner, and Chair Whistler all voted in favor, resulting in a unanimous 3-0 approval. No formal votes or binding decisions were taken regarding the Sanitation Division’s budget or fee structures; staff presented information to inform future discussions, but the committee did not adopt any changes at this time.

Discussion Highlights

Finance Director Tony McDowell provided updates on new staff hires, the American Rescue Plan (ARPA) grant process, and the status of the city’s annual audit. Regarding the audit, Assistant Finance Director Becky King noted that while the financial audit may be completed by November 18, the full filing is on hold pending the release of the ARPA single audit compliance supplement. She indicated the city is aiming for a November 30 deadline to avoid penalties, as the October 31 deadline may not be met.

Public Works staff presented a detailed review of the Sanitation Division, highlighting that the current service model, designed for single-family homes, is struggling to adapt to the growth of multifamily, mixed-use, and infill development. Sanitation Division Manager Jess Foster explained that these changes create challenges for collection routes and alley space. Budget Manager Taylor Floyd noted that of the division’s approximately $6 million budget, only about $300,000 consists of flexible operating costs, with the remainder tied to fixed expenses like personnel, fuel, and recycling contracts. Floyd stated that the "no change" budget option is no longer viable due to a lack of staffing resources to address unique operational issues.

Floyd also pointed out that the city is currently off-track for its 2035 waste reduction goal, having seen a 3% increase in landfill waste compared to the 2010 baseline, rather than the required 15% reduction. He suggested that illegal dumping may be exacerbated by county residents who are not required to pay for waste disposal services, potentially bringing waste into city limits. Chair Whistler proposed developing a "long-range solid waste master plan" to address operational challenges and waste reduction goals over the next 10 years. She also suggested considering small, incremental annual fee increases, similar to the Municipal Services District model, rather than large one-time increases. Additionally, Whistler emphasized the need for transparency in the ARPA grant process, stating that if grants are denied for not fitting criteria, the city should make that public and explain the reasoning.

Follow-ups

Several members and staff members outlined next steps during the meeting. Kim Marmon-Sacks, the new ARPA Project Manager, stated that the Request for Proposals (RFP) response deadline is November 15, and the evaluation team hopes to have recommendations ready for the City Council meeting on January 11. Chair Whistler stated she would take the issue of the city’s 50% waste reduction goal by 2035 to the Safety and Sustainability Committee to explore if the goal should be adjusted based on population growth. Councilwoman Kilgore stated she would continue conversations with the Tourism Development Authority (TDA) regarding a potential partnership to help fund city cleanliness efforts.

Impact

This meeting highlighted the financial and operational pressures facing the city’s Sanitation Division as it adapts to changing residential patterns. While no immediate fee changes were approved, the discussion underscored that the current budget structure is stretched thin, with limited flexibility for operational adjustments. The proposed long-range master plan and the review of waste reduction goals indicate a shift toward strategic, long-term planning for waste management. For residents, the focus on incremental fee increases and the review of the 2035 waste reduction target suggest that future budget discussions will weigh the costs of adapting to new development against the goals of sustainability and service reliability.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches