Public Safety Committee
October 26, 2021 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 7 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Public Safety Committee Meeting Recap: October 26, 2021
The City of Asheville Public Safety Committee met on October 26, 2021, to discuss the expansion of the Written Consent to Search Policy. The primary focus of the meeting was a debate over whether the current policy, which requires written consent for vehicle searches, should be extended to cover pedestrians, cyclists, and individuals in wheelchairs. The committee also addressed the approval of previous minutes and raised concerns regarding the population of the Buncombe County detention facility.
Key Decisions The committee voted unanimously (3 Ayes, 0 Nays) to approve the minutes from the previous meeting. Regarding the Written Consent to Search Policy, a motion was made by Councilwoman Kim Roney to recommend to the full Council that the policy be amended to include all modes of transportation. However, no second was offered, and no vote was taken; consequently, the motion did not proceed. The Chair stated that the committee would revisit the issue in approximately three months to allow for further data collection and analysis.
Discussion Highlights Police presented data indicating a significant decline in consent-based vehicle searches since the policy was implemented in October 2019. Police Chief David Zach stated that staff does not recommend extending the policy until additional data is collected to determine if pedestrians or cyclists are being subjected to illegal searches. He emphasized that requiring written consent during field encounters with pedestrians poses a safety risk because officers must keep their hands free and lack the protection of vehicle barriers. In response, Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed concern that the city is not currently collecting or making available all relevant data, viewing the situation as an opportunity to start that process. City Manager Deborah Campbell stated that the city would make a deliberate effort to collect the data necessary to make an informed decision. Additionally, Councilwoman Kim Roney raised concerns about the recent increase in the Buncombe County detention facility population and the City’s role in it.
Community Input Public comment was held at the beginning and end of the meeting, with no committee members or staff members responding directly to the comments.
- Beginning of Meeting: A public commenter representing the group "Be Loved Asheville" spoke in favor of expanding the policy, citing personal experiences of non-consensual searches. A resident supported the expansion, asking why people in vehicles have more rights than those walking or biking, and cited instances of police searching unhoused residents. A resident and retired pastor cited the Fourth Amendment, arguing that the right to be secure against unreasonable searches should apply to non-motorists to build trust.
- End of Meeting: A resident who had been following traffic stop data since 2016 argued that staff were using new criteria to delay the policy and requested the committee recommend the City Manager extend the policy to pedestrians and cyclists. They also requested a status update on two other policies passed in 2018. Another resident supported the expansion, arguing that the Chief’s safety concerns were not credible for trained officers given stable violent crime statistics. A resident challenged the assertion that consent searches occur during high-risk moments, arguing they happen after situations are secured. A recent arrival encouraged the committee to extend the policy to show that trust is being built. Finally, a resident expressed support for the police, arguing the committee should wait for more information before adding bureaucratic hurdles.
Follow-ups Police Chief David Zach stated that the Integrity Unit is working on reviewing cases to collect data on pedestrian and cyclist searches, starting with 2021 data and working backward. He also stated that the department intends to present a "deep dive" into traffic stops at the next month's Public Safety meeting to address resolutions passed in 2018. Councilwoman Kim Roney requested a future conversation with the City Manager regarding the City’s role in the increase of the detention facility population and the relationship with the Safety and Justice Challenge, which the Chair confirmed would be discussed.
Impact This meeting highlights the ongoing tension between officer safety protocols and community protections regarding search and seizure. While the committee did not vote to expand the written consent policy to pedestrians and cyclists, the decision to pause for three months to gather more data acknowledges the community's request for transparency and equitable protection under the Fourth Amendment. The commitment to collect data on pedestrian searches and review traffic stop practices aims to provide the factual basis needed for future policy decisions.
Meeting Video & Transcript