Skip to main content
  • 23 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On October 12, 2021, the City of Asheville’s Boards and Commissions Committee convened to address board vacancies, review annual reporting timelines, and prepare for upcoming full council actions. The meeting was chaired by Vice Mayor Shanika Smith, with Councilwoman Antoinette Mosley and Councilwoman Kim Roney participating. Staff members Ben Woody, Assistant City Manager, Michelle Smith, Deputy City Clerk, and Alex Smith, Assistant City Clerk, were present to provide updates.

Key Decisions and Votes

The committee began by unanimously approving the minutes from the September 12 meeting (3 Ayes, 0 Nays). The primary focus of the meeting was the recommendation of nominees for various city boards and commissions. For the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee (HIAC), the committee unanimously voted to recommend David Bartholomew for the single vacancy. Regarding the Human Relations Commission (HRCA), despite a request for a moratorium, the committee unanimously voted to recommend Harvey Dean Harrell for a seat.

The most extensive portion of the meeting involved the Noise Advisory Board, where the committee filled five seats. Unanimous votes were taken to recommend Jessica Thomason for the performing arts seat and Carmelo Pompliano for the acoustic engineering seat. For the three resident seats, Councilwoman Mosley moved to recommend Megan Riley, Rick Freeman, and Charles Beck. Councilwoman Roney proposed a friendly amendment to replace Megan Riley with Jeff Santiago for the West Asheville seat, which was adopted. The final recommendation for the resident seats was Jeff Santiago (West), Rick Freeman (East), and Charles Beck (Central). The committee also unanimously voted to recommend James Corbin for the restaurant industry seat and Anup Krishnan for the construction industry seat. Finally, the committee unanimously voted to recommend interviewing all six new applicants for the Planning and Zoning Commission, a recommendation that will be presented to the full council.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the discussion centered on the Human Relations Commission. Councilwoman Roney read an email from board chair Tonya Rodriguez, who strongly recommended a moratorium on new members until the Office of Equity and Inclusion has permanent staff, stating, "I do not want to risk a revolving door commission that is the expense of our time and effort due to non-permanent staff." Vice Mayor Smith responded by noting the upcoming retreat and the need for quorum, stating, "I do not see the logic behind not seating, not filling one vacancy, being that they're going into a retreat next month. It seems that if they have any vacancies that needs to be filled so that they can build the cohesiveness that she's asking for."

During the Noise Advisory Board discussions, the committee debated residency requirements and applicant qualifications. Councilwoman Roney suggested including a renter on the board, noting, "It seems to me that we have an opportunity to also have a renter, not just owners at the table." Councilwoman Mosley expressed concern about potential conflicts regarding the residency requirement for the acoustic engineering seat, stating, "Where I'm concerned is I feel like we're going to have this butting heads for the resident seat. So I'm trying to move somebody over from one to open up a space in the resident seat."

Follow-ups

Staff provided updates on two additional agenda items. Regarding annual reports, staff will reach out to board chairs and staff liaisons in the coming week to provide templates; reports are due by January 30, with the full report expected to be presented at the February meeting. Regarding the Board of Adjustment, the committee decided to re-advertise the vacancy as no applications were received. Additionally, staff noted that the full council will hear an update from Deborah Jones (TORQED Equity) and Brenda Mills (Interim Equity Inclusion Director) regarding the reparations commission at the council meeting on the evening of October 12, and applications for the reparations commission are expected to open on October 18.

Impact

These decisions ensure that key advisory bodies, including the Noise Advisory Board and the Human Relations Commission, have the necessary members to function and prepare for upcoming strategic sessions, such as the HRCA retreat. The recommendations for the Noise Advisory Board specifically aim to balance industry expertise with resident perspectives, including the inclusion of a renter, to address noise concerns in the community. The decision to interview all Planning and Zoning Commission applicants allows the full council to proceed with the appointment process for that body.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches