Human Relations Commission
August 19, 2021 at 5:30 PM
- 1 h 35 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The Human Relations Commission of Asheville held a meeting on August 19, 2021. The agenda included administrative updates, new business, working group reports, staff updates, and community announcements. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which was seconded by a commissioner; the Chair exercised their authority to adjourn the meeting without a roll call vote.
Key Decisions
No formal votes were taken on the minutes from the previous meeting or the current agenda. The Chair noted that the Secretary was unable to keep minutes for the last meeting, and no motion was made to approve the current agenda after the City Attorney advised it did not require approval. The only recorded motion was to adjourn the meeting, which was seconded by a commissioner.
Discussion Highlights
The meeting began with the introduction of Brenda Mills as the new Interim Equity and Inclusion Director and Erin Miles as the Assistant City Attorney supporting the Office of Equity and Inclusion. Working groups presented updates on health disparities, noting racial differences in vaccination rates, and school discipline, where data showed that Black students comprised 20.7% of the school population but 59.5% of in-school suspensions and 57.5% of out-of-school suspensions. One commissioner expressed concern about relying on police in schools, stating, "We need something to be done... instead of scaring our kids with these police officers."
Staff provided an update on the selection of a project manager for the city’s reparations study and discussed how the commission can support the new non-discrimination ordinance. The commission also reviewed potential future topics, including minority contract training, LGBTQ+ and ADA complaint processes, and environmental justice.
Significant community concerns were raised regarding the "exodus" of Black residents from Asheville due to cost of living and displacement. One commissioner stated, "We're not gaining black residents, we're losing them... It's because we can't survive here," while another noted this follows a history of intentional displacement in the 1980s and 1990s. Additionally, a commissioner resigned from the commission effective immediately, citing a belief that the body had become a "distraction" and "window dressing" that failed to acknowledge intersectionality. In response, another commissioner asked if the resigning member’s feelings might change in 30 days, and the Chair described the resignation as a "wake-up call" for the commission to "put whatever it is aside and to join together."
The meeting also addressed a local judge’s sentencing in a sexual assault case. A commissioner expressed outrage, stating, "Our justice system just failed us... This judge gets two years for touching our kids." The City Attorney responded, "We absolutely share your condemnation of the actions of this particular individual," but noted the office maintains independence from commenting on individual judges to provide unbiased service.
Follow-ups
Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. The Secretary (Commissioner Noyes) stated she would look for the minutes from the last meeting and follow up with the liaison. The Interim Equity and Inclusion Director (Brenda Mills) asked commissioners who submitted reports to email those reports to her by the next day for compilation. She also agreed to invite the reparations process manager to a future meeting and to call the commissioner who raised the issue regarding safety cameras in the Shiloh neighborhood. The Assistant City Attorney (Erin Miles) agreed to prepare a presentation on the new non-discrimination ordinance and complaint process for a future meeting. Finally, the City Attorney and staff agreed to look into the feasibility and scheduling requirements for a potential commission retreat in October.
Impact
This meeting highlighted ongoing disparities in health outcomes and school discipline within Asheville, as well as the significant social challenge of Black resident displacement. The resignation of a commissioner and the subsequent discussion underscored internal tensions regarding the commission's effectiveness and its relationship with the Equity and Inclusion department. The meeting also served as a platform for addressing community concerns about climate impacts and the justice system, while establishing next steps for supporting new non-discrimination efforts and planning future strategic sessions.
Meeting Video & Transcript