Historic Resources Commission
August 11, 2021 at 3:59 PM
- 3 h 43 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: August 11, 2021
The City of Asheville’s Historic Resources Commission (HRC) convened on August 11, 2021, to review five Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) applications within the Montford Historic District. The meeting began with the approval of the minutes from the July 2021 meeting, which passed with 6 ayes and 1 abstention. The Commission then addressed four completed CA applications and one new construction request that was deferred for further design review.
Key Decisions and Votes The Commission approved four CA applications and continued one item for future review.
- 240 Pearson Drive: The CA for modifications to an accessory structure (carriage house) and the installation of fencing and gates was approved with 7 ayes and 0 nays. Approval was conditional on the removal of a proposed dormer on the north elevation, its replacement with additional skylights, and the submission of revised elevations, gate details, and material specifications for staff review.
- 119 Cumberland Avenue: The CA for the modification of a non-contributing building for residential use was approved with 7 ayes and 0 nays. Conditions required the submission of all manufacturer’s specifications for doors, roofing, lighting, mechanical units, and patio materials for staff approval.
- 288 Montford Avenue: The CA for the installation of a fabric awning over a front porch balcony was approved with 7 ayes and 0 nays, with no exceptions or conditions.
- 95 Cherry Street (The Frugal Frame): The CA for a non-contributing structure was approved unanimously by roll call. The approval covered the replacement of deteriorating wood doors and windows and the installation of small metal ramps and handrails to address ADA compliance issues. A subsequent motion to issue the CA without conditions also passed unanimously.
- New Construction on Elizabeth Place: The Commission did not issue a CA for a new 3,500-square-foot primary structure. Instead, the item was continued to the September meeting by unanimous roll call vote to allow the applicant to address design feedback.
Discussion Highlights The most extensive discussion occurred regarding the new construction on Elizabeth Place. Staff and Commissioners focused on ensuring the design’s consistency with the neighborhood’s Craftsman/Bungalow aesthetic. Staff expressed concern that the proposed dormers were "really distracting" and too large for the front elevation, noting that such configurations are not typical for the style. Staff also advised that the proposed use of two separate roofing materials was inconsistent with past approvals, suggesting asphalt shingles would be more appropriate than metal for a bungalow-style house. Commissioner Will Hornaday questioned the placement of a small window to the left of the front door, suggesting a single casement or decorative window might look better, and noted that a round window felt like a "real interruption" without clear precedent. Chair Emily Kite emphasized that while standards do not explicitly ban dormers, they require style consistency with existing neighborhood examples.
For the 240 Pearson Drive project, Staff expressed concerns that the proposed fencing and gates were a "gray area" because gates are generally discouraged in the district. Commissioner Will Hornaday stated he was "on the fence" about the added dormer but leaned toward approving the door size originally approved in 2018. Applicant Mark Clif noted the team’s history with the HRC and their pride in a recent Griffin Award, indicating an intention to apply similar diligence to the carriage house project.
For 119 Cumberland Avenue, Staff described the proposed solution as "elegant" for navigating exposed concrete masonry units on the parking lot side. Commissioner Will Hornaday appreciated the team’s consideration of previous comments, calling it a "really successful solution."
Community Input During the review of 119 Cumberland Avenue, a resident living adjacent to the property provided public comment. The resident expressed support for the project, noting it was an improvement over a previous proposal due to fewer units. However, they raised concerns about large rear decks and balconies towering over their property. Their primary request was for the buyer to protect existing arborvitae trees along the property line to serve as a privacy hedge. In response, Staff noted that the site plan showed substantial landscaping on that side. An applicant clarified that the arborvitae are likely in the alleyway (off the applicant's property) and that the only tree proposed for removal was in the front. Chair Emily Kite asked if the concern was addressed in the application, and Commissioner Will Hornaday asked if tree preservation was a requirement being made.
Follow-Ups Staff agreed to follow up with the applicants for 240 Pearson Drive, 119 Cumberland Avenue, and 288 Montford Avenue in the next few days. For 119 Cumberland Avenue, an applicant agreed to have a surveyor determine the exact location of the arborvitae trees mentioned by the public commenter to clarify if they are on or off the property. For the Elizabeth Place new construction, the applicant requested a continuance to address the Commission’s feedback. Staff noted the resubmittal deadline for the next cycle is the following Wednesday. The applicant stated she would contact staff the next day to confirm if she could meet that deadline or if the item should be continued to October. Staff agreed to continue the item to September for now and wait for the applicant’s confirmation.
Impact These decisions allow for the completion of four renovation and accessibility projects within the Montford Historic District, including ADA-compliant modifications for a local business and residential conversions. The deferral of the Elizabeth Place new construction ensures that the design process continues to align with the historic character of the neighborhood, specifically regarding roof materials, dormer sizing, and window placement, before a final decision is made.
Meeting Video & Transcript