Skip to main content

Affordable Housing Advisory Commission

July 1, 2021 at 9:30 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jun 3 meetingNext: Sep 2 meeting
  • 2 h 4 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview On July 1, 2021, the City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee convened to address critical issues in the local housing market, review development applications, and update members on ongoing community development projects. The agenda included discussions on rising construction costs, the utilization of housing vouchers, and the impact of corporate investors on housing availability.

Key Decisions The committee took formal action on two primary items. First, the minutes from the previous meeting were reviewed and approved unanimously by roll call. Second, the committee voted on a recommendation regarding a return application for housing trust fund financing to convert six garages into affordable one-bedroom apartments. A motion was made to encourage projects involving "gentle density," such as garage and accessory dwelling unit (ADU) conversions, and to affirm that the use of the Housing Trust Fund is appropriate for these purposes. The motion was seconded and carried, with one member abstaining and all other voting members voting "Aye." Additionally, the committee voted on a recommendation for a "Luigi" land use incentive grant application for a new 86-unit development on Long Shoals Road, which includes 17 affordable units. A motion was made encouraging developers to use the Luigi process while requesting a balanced unit mix that avoids creating a sole class of units solely for affordability. This motion also carried, with one member abstaining and the remaining voting members voting "Aye."

Discussion Highlights Staff provided updates on several projects, including the status of 319 Biltmore, an upcoming Request for Proposals for down payment assistance, and the Cedar Hill purpose-built housing project. Staff also reported on the transition of approximately 50 individuals from the Red Roof Inn, a COVID-19 response site, to other housing arrangements. The committee discussed the challenges of the current housing market, noting rising construction costs and lumber prices. Chair Barry Bialik stated, "Average prices are at sky high news, new highs. It’s going to be, you know, it’s such a challenge we have for affordable homeownership for how to help turn that... affordable homeownership is becoming even more and more elusive."

A representative from the Housing Authority presented data on voucher usage, noting, "Our success rates are about 50%. So about 50% of the people that are issued a voucher are not finding a place and are staying where they’re at." The committee discussed the difficulties residents face in finding landlords who accept vouchers. Concerns were also raised regarding corporate ownership, with a member stating, "I just tried, it seems, I know we’re tracking home prices and availability and wondering just there’s some way we could either pull realtors or go through the register... to see how big an issue it is going forward." Regarding the Millstone project, a member commented on the unit mix, stating, "We have 12 of the units that were created as efficiencies, but they’re not renting out these efficiencies... So we’re just creating a second class of housing within the project for affordability purposes... I think that’s where you kind of get into that segregated housing issue." Staff member Paul D’Angelo advised that a motion on certain topics was beyond the scope of the committee, stating, "I would just like I did last time advise that I don’t think a motion at this point as this is beyond the scope of AHAC is appropriate... I just want to advise from a staff perspective that we are entering into unchartered territory here without the guidance of boards and commissions." Another member expressed a desire to support development, stating, "I’ve seen so many negative things recently that I’d like to encourage a few things... any developers coming to town need as much encouragement as we can."

Community Input One public commenter from a children’s community school organization spoke regarding the type of units being built for affordability. The commenter appreciated the committee’s discussion on ensuring developments include units suitable for families with children, rather than defaulting to studio apartments. They also raised the issue of American Rescue Plan (ARP) funds, requesting an open, community-engaged discussion on how to center the needs of children and families in housing affordability, and offered to share a toolkit from NC Child regarding ARP funding discussions. The Chair thanked the commenter, noting that the comment was related to the important discussions the committee had just held.

Follow-ups Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. A member agreed to send an email list of names and contact information for the "Build" and "Connect" task force members to facilitate scheduling. Another member volunteered to create a scheduling poll for the "Build" task force, and another for the "Connect" task force. A member agreed to look up property transfer records for LLCs and corporate names to determine the residency of owners, specifically analyzing a sample of homes sold for under $275,000 over the last three months. A staff member from the Housing Authority agreed to provide data on the waitlist for project-based units, including the unit breakdown. A member requested that the Thrive program come to the committee to speak, and a staff member indicated this would be a good idea. The Chair stated that the committee would look into options for residents regarding the ending of the eviction moratorium and the resulting debt load for the next meeting. Finally, a staff member stated they would try to reach out to a partner from Land of Sky Realtors regarding a possible outreach event in August or September.

Impact These discussions and decisions highlight the committee's focus on addressing the growing gap between housing costs and affordability. The approval of the garage conversion recommendation signals support for "gentle density" projects as a viable use of trust fund resources. The review of the Luigi application and the subsequent motion for a balanced unit mix reflects the committee's concern about preventing the segregation of affordable housing within developments. The data presented on voucher utilization underscores the practical barriers low-income residents face in securing housing, while the follow-up actions on corporate ownership and task force scheduling indicate an ongoing effort to gather data and coordinate efforts to stabilize the local housing market.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches