Planning & Zoning Commission
June 2, 2021 at 5:00 PM
- 2 h 6 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Recap: June 2, 2021
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission convened on June 2, 2021, to address the approval of previous minutes, two unfinished business items, and two new legislative public hearings. The agenda focused primarily on conditional rezoning requests, with the commission voting on two items and recessing two others for further review at a future date.
The commission began by approving the minutes from the May 5, 2021, meeting with revisions. A motion to approve the minutes, including additional comments regarding the Charlotte Street project, was made, seconded, and passed unanimously. The commission then turned to unfinished business, starting with a request for 70 Mills Gap Road to rezone from Industrial/Residential Single-Family Low Density to Residential Expansion Conditional Zone. The commission voted unanimously to deny this request, which will move to City Council with a negative recommendation.
The most contentious item of the evening was the conditional rezone of 17 properties along Charlotte Street, East Chestnut Street, Furman Avenue, and Baird Street to a Mixed Use Expansion Conditional Zone. An initial motion to deny the request failed with a vote of 3 ayes and 4 nays. Subsequently, a motion to approve the request passed with a vote of 4 ayes and 3 nays. This item will move to City Council with a positive recommendation. During the discussion, the developer’s attorney emphasized the site’s uniqueness, stating, "I think you'd be hard pressed to find a five to six acre site that could do what this site can do... This is a unique opportunity with a unique piece of property." The attorney also addressed affordability thresholds, noting, "If you're setting a new threshold that it's got to exceed 10% with no help from the city and no increase in the density, you are setting an insurmountable bar for the overwhelming majority of property owners and developers in the city."
The commission recessed two new legislative public hearings until the next meeting on July 7, 2021. The first was for 1617 Hendersonville Road, a request by the Deerfield Episcopal Retirement Community to rezone from Institutional/Residential Multifamily High Density to Commercial Expansion Conditional Zone. The second was for 66 Long Shoals Road, a request to rezone from Institutional to Residential Expansion Conditional Zone. Both recessions were approved unanimously. For the Hendersonville Road project, a traffic engineer presented data indicating 67 trips during the a.m. peak hour and 95 trips during the p.m. peak hour, noting that neither the DOT nor the city transportation department required a trip traffic impact analysis. For the Long Shoals Road project, a commissioner expressed safety concerns about pedestrians cutting across the road, stating, "My fear is that people are going to cut across right there and not go the extra 100, 200 yards down to the light to go across to Lake Julian. So I would love to see us work together to get something there to go across Longfield Road."
No public comment was accepted for the 70 Mills Gap Road or Charlotte Street items, as the Chair noted that comment periods had closed following the previous month's hearings. For the two recessed items, the Chair opened the floor for public comment, but a staff member reported no one was waiting in the queue, and the Chair closed the floor immediately.
Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Regarding the Charlotte Street project, the developer’s attorney stated that the client is in "active conversations with Paul D'Angelo" to deed restrict some existing Asheville Arms units to make them permanently affordable for 20 years, adding, "We are in good faith negotiations with Paul D'Angelo to add an additional 10%... We would have to get a commitment from city council for a Luigi grant for that to work... I can promise you this we're committed to trying to make that happen." The Chair stated, "I will be available for any questions" regarding the Charlotte Street materials. For the Deerfield project, a staff member offered to reach out to transportation staff to assist with a potential crosswalk improvement, and the developer’s attorney stated, "We are in the process of pulling together proposals to get that done" regarding test wells for geothermal energy. For the Long Shoals Road project, the applicant’s attorney stated, "We have talked to Paul [D'Angelo] in that process and we'll start pushing that forward next week" regarding the application for a Luigi grant to support affordable housing units. Additionally, a staff member stated, "I can be sure to make that available for anybody who is interested" regarding the updated list of B1 conditions submitted after the meeting materials were posted.
These decisions impact local land use and development in Asheville. The approval of the Charlotte Street rezone signals the commission's support for mixed-use development in that area, while the denial of the Mills Gap Road request maintains its current zoning classification. The recessed items for Hendersonville Road and Long Shoals Road will be revisited on July 7, 2021, allowing for further review of traffic, safety, and affordability concerns before final recommendations are made to City Council.
Meeting Video & Transcript