Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee
May 28, 2021 at 9:00 AM
- 1 h 23 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On May 28, 2021, the City of Asheville’s Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee (HIAC) held a virtual meeting to address housing challenges, review recent data, and determine the allocation of new federal funds. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of the 2021 Point-in-Time (PIT) count, and a detailed discussion on utilizing American Rescue Plan (ARP) funding to address homelessness in the region.
Key Decisions The committee approved the minutes from the March 26, 2021 meeting via a unanimous roll call vote. The primary decision of the meeting involved the use of American Rescue Plan (ARP) funds. A motion to recommend the use of direct ARP allocations to the City of Asheville and Buncombe County passed with a vote of 10-1. Subsequently, the committee voted to appoint a task force to identify specific recommendations for these funds; this motion passed 9-1-1, with one member voting "No" and one abstaining. During the vote, a councilwoman raised a point of order regarding the abstention, noting that advisory boards typically count non-votes as "Yes." The Chair asked the abstaining member if they wished to recuse themselves, but the member declined, stating their concern was about the task force composition rather than a conflict of interest. The Chair recorded the vote as passed. Finally, a motion to approve a recusal for a county employee member who had voted "No" on the previous motion was approved unanimously by the remaining voting members.
Discussion Highlights Staff presented the 2021 Point-in-Time count, which identified a total of 527 individuals. The data highlighted a significant increase in unsheltered individuals due to reduced shelter capacity during the pandemic and a rise in youth homelessness, while veteran homelessness decreased. Staff noted that 30% of the identified population is Black, Indigenous, or People of Color (BIPOC).
The committee discussed the high cost of housing and the difficulty in recruiting private landlords. Brian (Staff) stated, "From my desk, the most critical need we have in the community is more permanent supportive housing units available... We got rental assistance dollars... But, you know, and some of those resources are also allocated to rapid rehousing efforts. But again, it's dependent on having a sufficient supply of private sector landlords who are willing to rent."
David (Housing Authority) offered a differing perspective on equity, stating, "I disagree somewhat with Brian about the fact that just creating more Affordable or almost focused units will help solve the racial equity imbalance in our services. I think race neutral solutions do not solve those problems... So I think we need to take intentional steps to make sure that we are offering housing opportunities to people of color as we move forward with these projects."
Regarding the newly formed task force, Sarah (Committee Member) emphasized the need for appropriate representation, stating, "I would just want to make sure that at the outset, we're recruiting someone for the task force that has those connections and can represent appropriately... I do know that Meredith and David particularly have very engaged groups." Meredith (Homeward Bound) added, "I would recommend not just those with lived experience, but someone who is currently housed, but a client and receiving services, and at least one person who is unhoused so that you have both represented."
Follow-ups The committee agreed to form a task force to develop specific recommendations for ARP funds, with staff identifying a preliminary group to meet "sometime next week" to brainstorm the approach. Several staff and members agreed to provide specific information for future meetings:
- David (Housing Authority) agreed to look up and provide the current Fair Market Rent (FMR) figures.
- Parker Smith agreed to send demographic breakdown data from the first CDBG-CV contract to the committee.
- Paul D'Angelo (City Staff) agreed to bring back information regarding the City’s process for ARP funds and a summary of new CDBG-CV equity regulations.
- Brian (Staff) agreed to provide a more substantive report on the Point-in-Time count and system performance measures at the next meeting in July.
Impact This meeting is significant for residents as it establishes the framework for how approximately $27 million in direct ARP allocations to the City of Asheville and approximately $50.7 million to Buncombe County will be utilized to address homelessness. The committee’s focus on equitable representation and the inclusion of individuals with lived experience in the task force aims to ensure that the new federal funds address the specific needs of marginalized communities and those currently experiencing homelessness.
Meeting Video & Transcript