Human Relations Commission
May 20, 2021 at 5:30 PM
- 2 h 19 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On May 20, 2021, the Human Relations Commission of Asheville convened to address housing equity, police community engagement, and internal commission procedures. The meeting focused heavily on recommendations from the Houseless Working Group, transparency in working groups, and the scheduling of future meetings.
Key Decisions
The Commission adopted the revised agenda unanimously via roll call vote. Chair Tanya Rodriguez moved to appoint Commissioner Melanie Noyes as Secretary, a motion that passed unanimously.
The Commission voted on two primary recommendations from the Houseless Working Group. First, a recommendation to remove camping ordinances (City Code Chapter 12, Article 3, Sections 12.51 and 12.52) and redirect enforcement funds to sanitation passed with a vote of 6 Yes to 5 No. The "Yes" votes were cast by Chair Rodriguez, Commissioner Noyes, Commissioner Chandler, Commissioner Overfelt, Commissioner Coit, and Vice Chair Oliver. The "No" votes were cast by Commissioner Venable, Commissioner Fleurne-Devolo, Commissioner Weinbrenner, Commissioner Young, and Commissioner Jones.
Second, a recommendation to prohibit encampment removals three days before and after inclement weather passed by a majority vote. The "Yes" votes were cast by Chair Rodriguez, Commissioner Noyes, Commissioner Chandler, Commissioner Overfelt, Commissioner Coit, and Commissioner Weinbrenner. The "No" votes were cast by Commissioner Venable, Commissioner Fleurne-Devolo, and Commissioner Young. Commissioner Jones and Vice Chair Oliver did not vote on this item.
Regarding the refurbishment of the Martin Luther King Community Center, the Commission did not vote on the recommendation. Instead, Commissioner Daniel Young requested that the item be removed from the table, stating the community was already handling it. The item was deferred for further discussion.
A motion to extend the meeting length from 1.5 to 2 hours was denied. The "Yes" votes were cast by Commissioner Noyes, Commissioner Weinbrenner, Commissioner Tiffany Flourney-Double, and the Chair. The "No" votes were cast by Commissioner Venable, Commissioner Chandler, Commissioner Overfelt, Commissioner Quitt, and Commissioner Young. Commissioner Jones stated, "I said I wouldn't vote anymore."
A motion to begin the next HRCA agenda from where the current meeting left off passed by a majority vote. The "Yes" votes were cast by Commissioner Noyes, Commissioner Venable, Commissioner Chandler, Commissioner Overfelt, Commissioner Weinbrenner, and Commissioner Tiffany Flourney-Double. Commissioner Jones stated, "No more voting." The meeting was adjourned by a motion that passed.
Discussion Highlights
Commissioner Chris Weinbrenner proposed inviting a representative from the Asheville Police Department’s newly formed Community Engagement Division to present to the Commission. However, due to concerns raised by Commissioner Dolores Venable regarding the status of the Community Policing Advisory Committee (CPAC) and the need for full understanding before engaging, the item was tabled and moved to "Future Agenda Items."
Commissioner Young expressed frustration that while the city allocates $10 million to homelessness initiatives, Black residents with felony records are denied housing. He argued that the city is not helping its own community and that the recommendations were not equitable. Chair Rodriguez responded by stating that the recommendations create protections separate from funding issues and that the Commission could address fair housing practices in a future agenda item. Vice Chair Brandon Oliver also responded, acknowledging the frustration and stating that the Commission would continue to push for these issues to be on the agenda.
Commissioner Venable stated that she was not comfortable voting on the homelessness recommendations because the board lacked full information about the city council's recent $10 million vote and closed-door discussions. She expressed concern that the Commission was "rubber stamping" actions that had already been taken by the council and that the recommendations did not adequately address the specific needs of the Black community. Chair Rodriguez acknowledged her concerns and stated that the Commission would continue to work on the issues.
During the vote to extend meeting length, Commissioner Venable voted "No," stating: "I'm not going to devote no more time than I have to. Nobody's paying me... So I'm not going to just waste no more time on my month like this... If you really want to be here, you just volunteer your time because you care about people." Commissioner Chandler voted "No," stating: "I have a toddler and a pregnant wife. I'm gonna go with no." Commissioner Weinbrenner voted "No" but added: "I feel like everybody should be in work groups. I don't think that they're exclusionary and they help us have these meetings a lot more succinctly and stay focused. So my vote is a no, but I'm thumbs up for work groups."
Commissioner Tiffany Flourney-Double stated: "For the record, you can just call me Commissioner Dabolo."
Community Input
The transcript summary does not report any remarks by members of the public. All comments recorded in the summary were made by Commission members or staff.
Follow-ups
Staff Liaison Richard White agreed to confirm access to the shared folder for public input emails and to provide clarification on what happens to the hotel housing contract after June 30, 2021. Commissioner Weinbrenner agreed to draft a letter regarding the Martin Luther King Community Center refurbishment and to contact Commissioner Young to gather more information. The Commission explicitly agreed to pick up the agenda from where they left off at the next meeting.
Impact
These decisions establish new protections regarding encampment removals during inclement weather and direct the removal of specific camping ordinances, shifting enforcement resources toward sanitation. The deferral of the Martin Luther King Community Center refurbishment recommendation allows for further dialogue between the Commission and the community regarding the city's role in repairs. The agreement to continue the agenda at the next meeting ensures that unresolved topics, including police community engagement and fair housing practices, will remain on the Commission's docket.
Meeting Video & Transcript