Audit Committee
May 20, 2021 at 3:08 PM
- 1 h 3 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The City of Asheville Audit Committee convened on May 20, 2021, to review financial audit progress, contract management updates, and internal audit activities. The session included the introduction of a new committee member and the approval of previous meeting minutes.
Key Decisions
The committee’s primary formal action was the approval of the minutes from the March 3, 2021 meeting. A motion to approve these minutes was made and seconded. The vote was taken by roll call, with all five voting members—Susan Hutchinson, Andrew Emory, Amy Kemp, Gwynne Wissler, and Chair Scott Powell—voting in favor. Although Gwynne Wissler initially abstained due to a technical issue, she voted "Aye" after clarification, resulting in a unanimous 5-0 vote. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn, which also passed unanimously by a 5-0 roll call vote.
Discussion Highlights
The meeting began with the welcome of Andrew Emory to the Audit Committee. Staff then provided updates on several key areas. Tony McDowell, Director of Finance, reported that the department was approximately six weeks late in submitting the previous year’s audit but stated that the city is making "really good progress" through staffing changes and process improvements. He noted that external auditors are expected on-site on June 21st.
Patricia, representing Internal Audit, provided an overview of the city’s management of $26.2 million in American Rescue Plan (ARP) funds. She clarified that because her current role involves managing these funds, it compromises her independence, meaning she will not perform an internal audit on them; instead, the funds will likely be subject to a single audit by external auditors. She also reported on the ethics hotline, noting that in 2020, the city received four reports (two discrimination complaints and two policy violations), and in 2021, two reports (one policy violation and one unsubstantiated embezzlement claim). She observed that recent policy violations have largely involved mask policy compliance.
A significant portion of the discussion involved an exchange regarding an ethical issue involving a council member and a newspaper. Amy Kemp stated that as a CPA required to serve on the committee, she is held to AICPA standards and does not "back down" from them when hearing ethics-related information. Chair Scott Powell responded that the Audit Committee is "not the venue" for such matters, stating, "If you're going to blindside a council person in this meeting... that needs to go at the city council level or Gwen personally." Patricia agreed with the Chair, stating, "Amy, I'm going to agree with Scott and I think we're really going off the rails."
Follow-ups
Staff members explicitly agreed to provide further updates at the committee’s August meeting. Patricia from Internal Audit committed to presenting the updated contracting and purchasing policy, potentially alongside a staff member involved in its creation, and to provide an update on contract management audit findings and procedures. She also agreed to provide an update on financial audit preparation and the year-end close process. Additionally, Tony McDowell stated that the Finance Department hopes to announce and post a position for an Assistant Director of Accounting Services "next week" to bolster staff capacity. Patricia also agreed to send the committee the contract and staff report regarding a new audit contract that City Council is scheduled to approve on Tuesday night.
Impact
These discussions highlight the city’s ongoing efforts to improve financial transparency and operational efficiency. The focus on correcting audit delays and implementing digital workflows for contract management aims to strengthen internal controls. Furthermore, the clarification regarding the Internal Audit role and ARP funds ensures that residents understand the specific scope of oversight applied to federal relief money, which will be audited by external parties rather than the city’s internal audit staff.
Meeting Video & Transcript