Skip to main content
  • 1 h 52 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission held a meeting on May 14, 2021. The agenda focused primarily on the commission’s initial review of two major development projects under a new design review framework, as well as updates on citywide initiatives including the South Slope Vision Plan, parking rates, and the revised noise ordinance.

Key Decisions The commission approved the minutes from the February 26 and March 12, 2021, meetings unanimously (11-0). Additionally, the body voted to approve updates to Article 6, subitems B and C of the rules of procedure regarding temporary subcommittees and working groups; this motion passed 10-1. The meeting concluded with a motion to adjourn. No formal votes were taken on the design or approval of the development projects discussed during the meeting.

Discussion Highlights The central discussion involved the Four Points Sheraton mixed-use development and 120 Biltmore Avenue. Staff presented details indicating that both projects include significant numbers of "extended stay" hotel units alongside residential condominiums. For the Four Points Sheraton, staff clarified that the inclusion of extended stay units was a late addition to the proposal, confirmed only that week. Commissioner Andrew Fletcher expressed dismay at this shift in use, noting his enthusiasm had waned as the project’s function changed. Regarding 120 Biltmore Avenue, Commissioner Ruth Summers raised specific concerns regarding insufficient parking, noting that 59 spaces for 80 guest rooms and three condominiums was inadequate.

A significant portion of the debate centered on the implications of "extended stay" units, with several commissioners questioning whether these units function similarly to short-term vacation rentals. Commissioner Robin Raines questioned the distinction between extended stay units and short-term rentals, while Commissioner Guillaume Rodriguez argued that the extended stay designation was being used as a loophole to create short-term hotel use. Chair Brian Moffitt emphasized that the commission’s role is to focus on policy and process rather than purely aesthetic design, stating that design issues should remain with the Design Review Committee, while the commission should address policy, procedures, and non-design concerns. Commissioner Sage Turner affirmed the commission’s advisory role, encouraging members to voice strong feelings about the added hotel use to City Council.

Other agenda items included the South Slope Vision Plan, where staff outlined the plan’s five themes and ten key initiatives and requested feedback on time allocation for deeper review. Staff also provided updates on the city budget process, parking rate changes, Open Space Task Force recommendations, the removal of the Vance Monument, and the status of the revised noise ordinance. In response to resident concerns, the Chair stated the commission will likely schedule a meeting on June 11 to review the revised noise ordinance. Additionally, Commissioner Steven Lee Johnson suggested the commission recommend that the city adopt the saw-cut sidewalk scoring pattern used on Haywood Street as a standard for all downtown projects, citing its cleanliness and accessibility benefits for disabled pedestrians.

Community Input A pre-recorded voicemail regarding the noise ordinance was acknowledged. No public comments were recorded regarding the Vance Monument.

Follow-ups Staff committed to distilling the commission’s feedback on the development projects, forwarding design-related comments to the Design Review Committee, and sharing non-design concerns (such as parking and extended stay usage) with City Council and the Planning and Zoning Commission. Regarding the South Slope Vision Plan, staff agreed to send the draft plan to commission members for individual review and coordinate with working groups to review specific sections prior to the next meeting. The plan will be released for public comment for three to four weeks before returning to the commission for potential endorsement. Staff confirmed that new parking rates, including a free first hour and a 12-hour monthly option, are scheduled to roll out on July 1. Staff noted the revised noise ordinance draft is scheduled to go to the City Council’s Public Safety Committee on May 25 and the full Council on June 22.

Impact This meeting marked the commission’s first application of a new design review framework to major downtown projects. The discussions highlight ongoing community and commission scrutiny regarding the integration of hotel-style "extended stay" units into residential developments, particularly concerning parking adequacy and the distinction between long-term lodging and short-term rentals. Furthermore, the commission is actively engaging with the South Slope Vision Plan and preparing for the implementation of new downtown parking rates, which will directly affect how residents and visitors use downtown parking facilities starting in July.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches