Mountain Community Capital Fund Operating Committee
May 7, 2021 at 9:30 AM
- 1 h 2 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On May 7, 2021, the Mountain Community Capital Fund Operating Committee of the City of Asheville convened to review its portfolio, discuss grant applications, and consider loan requests. Jeff Kaplan, Vice Chair, presided over the meeting in the absence of Chair Lynn Smith, who joined later in the session. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a review of a grant pre-application, a logo update, and the evaluation of two loan presentations.
Key Decisions
The committee approved the minutes from the April 9, 2021 meeting. A motion to approve was made by Tim Love and seconded by Tony McDowell, passing unanimously with a 5-0 vote. Later in the meeting, with quorum restored, the committee voted on a $50,000 working capital and equipment loan presented by Mountain BizWorks. The motion to approve was made by Rachel Nygaard, and the vote passed unanimously by a 5-0 show of hands. The committee also agreed to schedule a special meeting for the following week to address a pending loan presentation that could not be voted on earlier due to a lack of quorum. No vote was taken on the proposed logo update because the committee lost quorum before the discussion concluded.
Discussion Highlights
The committee discussed the pre-application for the Dogwood Health Trust grant, settling on categorizing the fund as a "quasi-government entity" with an incorporation date of 2019. The group addressed the sensitive issue of collecting demographic data for board members to meet grant requirements, deciding to handle this via an offline survey rather than in public. Dee Williams of Dee Williams & Company recommended that this process occur on a subcommittee level, noting her experience with similar pre-applications.
Regarding the fund’s portfolio, the committee reviewed loan tracking, 1% fee collection, and repayment monitoring. Yaseline Gonzalez of Mountain BizWorks presented two loans: a $15,000 working capital loan for informational purposes and the $50,000 loan that was subsequently approved. Gonzalez emphasized the urgency of the latter, stating, "This client has been waiting for a few months now, and it's critical that we get some funding to him."
The committee also discussed potential partnerships with the Community Foundation and local governments receiving American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds. Rachel Nygaard of Buncombe County suggested, "It seems like there's a potential opportunity here for a conversation with the existing local government partners or potential new local government partners to invest in the fund." Tony McDowell of the City of Asheville responded, "I think that would be a great idea to include some of that funding for the Mountain Community Capital Fund."
A significant portion of the meeting was impacted by quorum issues. When member Dee Williams left the call, the committee lost quorum, preventing a vote on the logo update. Jeff Kaplan expressed frustration with the situation, stating, "I am personally disheartened and I think it's a disservice to the community that we don't have a quorum here, that we can't vote and release funds that are ready to go, which is the whole point of this committee." Quorum was restored when Chair Lynn Smith joined the meeting late.
Follow-ups
Jeff Kaplan agreed to send an email to committee members regarding the demographic survey for the Dogwood Health application and to include a call for volunteers to join the subcommittee for the Dogwood follow-up. Tony McDowell, Tim Love, and Rachel Nygaard agreed to follow up offline to explore potential partnerships with local governments regarding ARPA funds. Yaseline Gonzalez agreed to connect with the correct contact at Self-Help to send the outstanding 1% fees and to see if a fund manager from the Catalyst Fund could speak at a future meeting. Angelica Driver, City Staff, agreed to send the updated loan tracking sheet to the committee via email. Staff also agreed to work with the City and County clerks to schedule the special meeting for next week.
Impact
This meeting resulted in the approval of a $50,000 loan, providing immediate financial support to a local business client who had been waiting for funding. The committee’s decision to handle demographic data collection offline ensures that sensitive information is gathered in a private manner to satisfy grant requirements. Additionally, the agreement to schedule a special meeting for the following week ensures that the pending loan presentation can be addressed promptly, allowing the committee to continue its mission of releasing funds to eligible borrowers.
Meeting Video & Transcript