Skip to main content

Multimodal Transportation Commission

April 28, 2021 at 3:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Mar 24 meetingNext: Jun 23 meeting
  • 2 h 14 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Multimodal Transportation Commission Meeting Recap: April 28, 2021

The City of Asheville’s Multimodal Transportation Commission held a virtual meeting on April 28, 2021, to review infrastructure updates, address membership changes, and discuss structural reforms for the city’s transit operations. The session covered a wide range of topics, including the draft right-of-way closure policy, the Merriman Avenue project, transit budgeting, bike share plans, and citywide speed limits. Staff and committee representatives provided detailed updates on ongoing projects from the Greenway, Bike and Pedestrian, and Transit committees, focusing on safety improvements and operational developments.

The commission took several formal actions during the meeting. The agenda and the minutes from the March 24, 2021 meeting were both approved unanimously with five ayes. Regarding membership, the commission unanimously voted to remove Dennis Wenzel from the Greenway Committee and appoint him to an at-large seat. A motion was made to table the item concerning Michael Stratton’s status—specifically his removal from the Bike and Pedestrian Task Force to an at-large position—to ensure accurate documentation; the chair indicated a formal vote was not strictly required for tabling in this context. The most significant decision of the meeting was a 5-1 vote to recommend that City Council revisit the structure of the current transit subcommittee. The recommendation aims to elevate the Transit Committee to a standalone commission reporting directly to City Council, allowing for more direct access to policymakers, monthly meetings, and potential regional transit conversations. Michael Stratton voted against the motion, citing dissatisfaction with the wording and a desire to ensure the body maintains a direct line to Council via a liaison.

Discussion highlights included a focus on the benefits and risks of creating a standalone transit commission. Chair Dennis Wenzel stated that residents and visitors deserve the best possible transportation system and supported the idea of a group focused specifically on transit information. Staff member Kim noted that a standalone commission could allow for a more focused use of staff time to advise Council on transit as a core service. Commissioner Maggie expressed concern about "siloing" but suggested that the City Council liaison to the Multimodal Transportation Commission could also serve as the liaison to transit to connect policy across both groups. Commissioner Joe Archibald viewed the move as a first step toward a potential Asheville Buncombe Regional Transit Authority, while Commissioner Randy Warren emphasized the need to look at the bigger picture, including whether an authority structure might be more appropriate than a commission.

Public input was received on two specific items. One resident submitted a written comment supporting the Transit Committee becoming a standalone commission, which the chair noted before the discussion began. During the review of the draft right-of-way closure policy, a public commenter asked whether the city should charge more than the current fees to generate revenue for transit. In response, Commissioner Joe Archibald agreed that fees should align with actual land value and suggested using closures as a "carrot" for projects providing public benefits, while acknowledging legal constraints. Commissioner Maggie supported raising fees to manage public assets in the public's best interest and suggested asking legal to review whether the city can adjust fees based on development products. Staff member Jessica Crouch clarified that the current fee is $4,000, split between advertising and staff time, and noted that any additional revenue would require investigation into legal mechanisms and potential nexus requirements.

Staff and committee members provided updates on various infrastructure projects. The Greenway Committee noted the official naming and soft opening of the Greenway, which was well-attended; the Mayor highlighted that the project involved community members for over 20 years and described it as a model for future citywide projects. The Bike and Pedestrian Task Force raised significant safety concerns regarding the Amboy Road/Wilma Dyke Greenway Bridge, noting it lacks adequate width for pedestrians and cyclists. NCDOT is contributing $300,000 for short-term improvements, and the task force is discussing adding a three-way stop on the west side and an all-stop cycle on the east side. Commissioner Randy Warren praised NCDOT for addressing the issue in the short term with a long-term vision. Other updates included the repaving of Meadow Road with wider shoulders and a striped buffer, and the repaving of Richmond Hill Road with forward shoulders to accommodate truck traffic. Staff also reported on the reinstatement of state maintenance funds and the receipt of federal stimulus funds for the transit budget.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the meeting. Staff member Kim agreed to type up a report capturing individual comments regarding the Transit Commission recommendation to share with the full commission before sending it to City Council. Staff member Jessica Crouch stated that the commission will bring the draft right-of-way closure policy back with changes after further legal consultation. She confirmed that a joint meeting with NCDOT regarding the Merriman Avenue project is scheduled for May 3, 2021, and that she had sent a timeline history and staff report to the commission via email. Additionally, Jessica Crouch proposed dedicating 30 minutes of the next meeting to revisit bike share recommendations (excluding scooters) and agreed to add a revisit of the absolute ban on e-scooters to a future agenda item. City staff agreed to present a detailed review of the Biltmore-McDowell Corridor Study at a future Bike and Pedestrian Task Force meeting.

The meeting concluded with staff noting that they are currently correcting GIS data for the citywide default speed limit reduction to 25 mph. The commission adjourned with no further business. The next meeting is scheduled for May 26, 2021.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches