Governance Committee
April 27, 2021 at 1:00 PM
- 13 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Governance Committee Meeting Recap: April 27, 2021
The City of Asheville Governance Committee met on April 27, 2021, to review the minutes from February and discuss a proposed non-discrimination ordinance. The committee’s primary focus was evaluating the legal framework and enforcement mechanisms of the proposed legislation before sending it to the full City Council.
Key Decisions The committee unanimously approved the minutes from February. Following the approval of the minutes, the committee voted unanimously to move the proposed non-discrimination ordinance forward to the full City Council for a vote that same evening. The motion to forward the ordinance was made and seconded, with all three voting members recording an "Aye."
Discussion Highlights City Attorney Brad Branham presented the proposed non-discrimination ordinance, explaining that it aims to prevent discrimination in private employment and public accommodations, such as restaurants, retail stores, and short-term rentals, while also assisting those facing discriminatory practices in housing. Branham noted that the ordinance aligns the city with the recently adopted Buncombe County ordinance and advances the city’s equity and inclusion goals.
The presentation detailed the ordinance’s protected classes, which include race, natural hair or hairstyles, ethnicity, creed, color, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, national origin or ancestry, marital or familial status, pregnancy, veteran status, religious belief or non-belief, age, and disability. Regarding enforcement, Branham explained that the process prioritizes education, persuasion, and voluntary conciliation agreements. If voluntary resolution fails, the city may issue civil penalties of $100 per incident per day and seek injunctive relief, though no criminal penalties are included. Complaints would be filed with the Office of Equity and Inclusion, using a "reasonable cause" standard for investigations, with appeals available to the Office of Equity and Inclusion director or a panel consisting of the city manager, city human relations director, and city attorney within 10 days of a final decision.
Councilwoman Kim Roney acknowledged concerns that the fines might be insufficient compared to traffic tickets and noted the need for capacity building for the Office of Equity and Inclusion. She stated, "As a person of faith, I know that my religious freedoms are protected by the First Amendment... protection against discrimination in employment and public accommodations is not yet protected at the federal or state level, which is why we are among the municipalities in North Carolina passing these non-discrimination ordinances." She added, "This is a starting point and we have farther to go."
Mayor Esther Manheimer thanked City Attorney Brad Branham for the work done behind the scenes, noting that the legislative landscape had been a "moving target" as other municipalities developed their own ordinances. She remarked, "It's kind of amazing to me that we're here at this point. So that's really exciting." Mayor Manheimer also noted that if the ordinance is adopted, the city retains the ability to make amendments to tighten or strengthen specific areas as needed.
Follow-ups The Governance Committee directed the non-discrimination ordinance to the full City Council for a vote on the evening of April 27, 2021. If adopted by the full Council, the ordinance is scheduled to take effect on July 1, 2021, allowing time for training and education.
Impact This decision is significant for residents as it establishes a local framework to address discrimination in employment and public spaces, areas currently not protected at the federal or state level in North Carolina. By advancing the ordinance to the full Council, the committee has set the stage for the city to potentially implement these protections, which would provide a mechanism for residents to report and resolve discriminatory practices through the Office of Equity and Inclusion.
Meeting Video & Transcript