City Council Retreat – Day 1 Morning
March 31, 2021 at 10:07 AM
- 5 h 13 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Retreat: Day 1 Morning Recap
On March 31, 2021, the City Council of Asheville convened for the first day of a strategic planning and team-building retreat. The session, facilitated by Nicholas Beeman, focused on establishing foundational values, defining the council’s purpose, and creating a framework for effective governance. The meeting was closed to the public, involving only council members and staff, and no formal legislative votes or motions were taken.
The discussion began with an examination of leadership philosophy and personal motivations. Mayor Esther Manheimer noted the historic composition of the majority-new council and the unique challenges of the current moment, including the pandemic and social unrest. Facilitator Nicholas Beeman emphasized that leaders must "turn into the moment" rather than turn away, comparing them to first responders who run toward a fire. Council members shared their personal "whys" for entering public service, citing themes of service, equity, justice, and duty. For instance, Council Member Antanette Mosley stated her goal was to speak up specifically for Black women in discussions surrounding reparations, while Council Member Sandra Kilgore expressed that her motivation was to be an example for her son.
A significant portion of the meeting addressed the challenges of governance and the city’s evolving identity. Staff noted the tension between abstract public desires, such as the need for more housing, and specific opposition to individual projects. City Manager Deborah described this dynamic as causing "whiplash" and characterized the current governance model as "evolving" and "messy" due to the city’s transition from a small-town structure to a larger municipal entity without an established rulebook. The group discussed the difficulty of balancing economic growth with quality of life and the lack of consensus on the city’s long-term direction.
The council also engaged in a self-assessment of team health using a framework that distinguishes between "good teams" and "great teams." The group identified execution, self-leadership, and potential as current strengths, citing recent actions such as monument removal and school board elections. Conversely, they identified active trust, clarity/alignment, and straight talk communication as areas needing improvement. The facilitator used a Colin Powell quote to emphasize that loyalty requires full participation in decision-making, followed by executing the final decision as if it were one’s own idea. The council distinguished between "agreement" (thinking the same way) and "unity" (committing to the team’s decision even if it differs from individual preference), with one member summarizing the sentiment: "We don't have to see eye to eye, but we need to walk side by side."
To improve collaboration, the group explored specific behaviors, including the "Bus" Metaphor, which advocates keeping teammates in the loop before speaking to constituents or media to avoid "gotcha moments." They also discussed the importance of assuming positive intent and checking for understanding to prevent misinterpretation. One member advocated for "embracing the process and not the results," while another noted that Asheville tends to "sacrifice the good for the perfect" and expressed a desire to accept a lack of perfection for actual movement. The council agreed that a clear, repeatable process for handling disagreements and making decisions must be developed, and that once a priority is "locked in," changing it requires a formal process to prevent ad-hoc shifts in direction.
Follow-ups Staff, led by City Manager Deborah, agreed to build a clear, repeatable process for decision-making and community engagement to help the council move from disagreement to agreement and execution; this process will be brought to the council for approval. The facilitator requested that each council member come to the next session with one recommendation for a team agreement. Additionally, the facilitator stated that a "dashboard" or "wheel" referencing the team health framework would be sent via email that evening for members to review. The group agreed to reconvene the next morning to continue the discussion on priorities, starting with those created by the predecessor team.
Impact This retreat serves as a foundational step for the new council, aiming to establish internal norms for communication, trust, and decision-making. By identifying specific weaknesses in trust and communication and agreeing to develop formal processes for handling disagreements, the council is working to create a more cohesive and effective governance structure. These internal changes are intended to help the council navigate the complex challenges of the city’s growth and the diverse needs of its residents.
Meeting Video & Transcript